Rushing dominance, defensive grit, but special teams struggles. Discover Michigan's season grades, uncovering strengths and critical weaknesses.
After reviewing nine games of the 2025 season, Michigan's offense has earned a C+, the defense B+, and the special teams a C-. The Wolverines' 7-2 record under head coach Sherrone Moore is a tale of three dramatically different phases, with offensive and defensive strengths often overcoming issues on special teams and inconsistencies in the passing game.
Offense: Grade C+
The Michigan offense has been a dominant ground force but has shown limitations in the air.
- Rushing attack: The strength of the offense is an elite ground game, led by running back Justice Haynes, who is a leading rusher nationally, but also on the mend from injury. The offensive line has opened significant holes for Haynes and Jordan Marshall. This success on the ground has been a consistent driver of Michigan's offensive production.
- Passing game: Inconsistency and growing pains from freshman quarterback Bryce Underwood and an underwhelming wide receiver corps have hampered the passing game, which ranks 104th nationally in yards per game. While Underwood has shown flashes of his talent, his development and the receivers' ability to make plays will be crucial for the final stretch of the season. Drops have been another main issue which should be addressed during Michigan’s bye week.
- Red Zone struggles: The offense has occasionally struggled to convert opportunities into touchdowns, particularly inside the red zone. If the Wolverines want to make a top 12 spot, they must convert when in close, it’s as simple as that.
Defense: Grade B+
Despite losing key players, the Michigan defense has remained a strong unit, although with some inconsistencies.
- Defensive front: The front seven is a strong, veteran-led group that has maintained its physicality and prowess against the run. The defensive line, though reshaped, has continued to be a national strength. Derrick Moore and Jaishawn Barham have been beasts off the edge, and a big reason why Michigan is able to create pressure.
- Secondary: The secondary has been the more inconsistent unit, with the cornerback position showing some vulnerability against elite passing attacks. The Safety position would greatly benefit from having Rod Moore back, but Jyaire Hill has done a nice job without him so far.
- Points allowed: Despite some uneven performances, the defense has kept the team in games, ranking 17th nationally in opponent points per game.
Special teams: Grade C-
Special teams have been the Wolverines' biggest liability and a significant source of frustration.
- Return game: Both the punt and kick return units have been largely ineffective, ranking near the bottom of the FBS.
- Kicking and punting: Kicker Dominic Zvada has been less consistent than last season, while the punting unit, led by Hudson Hollenbeck, has had its struggles, not putting Michigan in great spots to succeed.
- Field position issues: The special teams' shortcomings have often put the offense in unfavorable field position, creating additional pressure on an inconsistent passing attack.
Overall assessment
Michigan's 7-2 record is a fair reflection of their season so far. While the dominant rushing attack and solid defense have secured wins, offensive inconsistency (passing game) and special teams’ issues have prevented the team from reaching its full potential. As the team navigates its bye week, addressing these weaknesses will be critical for a strong finish and a potential playoff push. My overall grade for the team through 9 games would be a B-.