• Powered by Roundtable
    Brady Farkas
    Brady Farkas
    Oct 15, 2025, 18:45
    Updated at: Oct 15, 2025, 18:45

    The Blue Jays were linked to free agent Alex Bregman last offseason. With Bregman now headed for free agency, could they attempt a run at him again?

    The Toronto Blue Jays made a run at free agent Alex Bregman last offseason and struck out, but with news on Tuesday that Bregman is opting-out of his deal with the Boston Red Sox, could they attempt to try again?

    It seems like it makes sense in a lot of ways, but it also comes with some hiccups and real question marks. Let's dive in:

    What works about this

    Simply put, Bregman is a good player. He's 31 years old, about to be 32, and he brings everything you could want. He's played 145 games or more in three of the last four seasons, has power (18 home runs in 114 games this season), leadership qualities and a real pedigree.

    He's a three-time All-Star, a two-time World Series winner, a Gold Glover and a Silver Slugger. He's also been to the playoffs nine times in 10 years and has a winning history.

    If the Blue Jays fall short of winning the World Series this year, he could be seen as the missing piece for 2026, helping lengthen an already deep lineup.

    What doesn't work about this

    The money will remain a question. He's opting out of a two-year and $80 million deal, suggesting he wants significantly more than that.

    The Jays just gave Vladimir Guerrero Jr. a $500 million extension, which came after signing Anthony Santander for $92 million, which followed trading for Andres Gimenez and his deal, worth nearly $100 million.

    Toronto has shown they are willing to pay to win, but there is a limit for everyone. Is this that limit?

    And how does Bo Bichette factor into things? If Toronto is going to spend money on a free agent infielder, wouldn't they spend it on a younger option, who is also a homegrown player?

    Furthermore, Ernie Clement was just named a Gold Glove finalist at third base. Maybe Toronto is happy with his contributions and will use any available money elsewhere.

    Chris Bassitt and Max Scherzer are both free agents as well.... the Jays do need pitching.

    For now

    The Jays will attempt to get back into the American League Championship Series. They trail the series 2-0 and will take the field on Wednesday night at 8:08 p.m. ET in Seattle.

    Shane Bieber will pitch against George Kirby.