• Powered by Roundtable
    Tom Brew
    Tom Brew
    Nov 12, 2025, 17:53
    Updated at: Nov 12, 2025, 18:28

    Stephen Vogt has been the manager of the Cleveland Guardians for two years now. Both seasons ended the same way, with the Guardians claiming an American League Central division title and Vogt being named AL Manager of the Year.

    Two-for-two isn't bad. He's the first AL manager to repeat since Tampa Bay's Kevin Cash did it in 2020 and 2021.

    The 41-year-old Vogt played 10 years in the majors and was Seattle's bullpen coach in 2023 before the Guardians hired him to replace Terry Francona. The move has worked out well. He received 17 of the 30 first-place votes.

    Here's the story from Guardians Roundtable writer Tommy Wild.

    Guardians’ Stephen Vogt Shares the Credit After Winning Manager of the Year Guardians’ Stephen Vogt Shares the Credit After Winning Manager of the Year Stephen Vogt has now won back-to-back Manager of the Year Awards, but made sure to acknowledge the work the entire Cleveland Guardians organization has done.

    Toronto's John Schneider, who got 10 first-place votes, was second. Seattle Dan's Wilson and Boston's Alex Cora were third and fourth, respectively. Both got one first-place vote. A.J. Hinch of Detroit was fifth, and Houston's Joe Espada was sixth.

    Cleveland made an amazing comeback to win the AL Central this year. They trailed Detroit by 15½ games in early July, and were still 11 games back in early September, a game under .500 at 69-70 on Sept. 4.

    But went 19-4 to finish the season, passing the Tigers on the final day of the year. They went 5-1 vs. the Tigers in the final month. Erasing that 15½-game deficit was the largest comeback in Major League Baseball history.

    They couldn't stay hot in the postseason, though, losing a three-game wild-card series to Detroit 2-1..

    Here is a list of all AL Manager of the Year winners since 2000.

    AL Managers of the Year 2000 to 2025

    2000 — Jerry Manuel, Chicago White Sox
    2001 — Lou Piniella, Seattle Mariners
    2002 — Mike Scioscia, Anaheim Angels
    2003 — Tony Pena, Kansas City Royals
    2004 — Buck Showalter, Texas Rangers
    2005  — Ozzie Guillen, Chicago White Sox
    2006 — Jim Leyland, Detroit Tigers
    2007 — Eric Wedge, Cleveland Indians
    2008 — Joe Maddon, Tampa Bay Rays
    2009 — Mike Scioscia, Anaheim Angels
    2010 — Ron Gardenhire, Minnesota Twins

    2011 — Joe Maddon, Tampa Bay Rays
    2012 — Bob Melvin, Oakland Athletics
    2013 — Terry Francona, Cleveland Indians
    2014 — Buck Showalter, Baltimore Orioles
    2015 — Jeff Bannister, Texas Rangers
    2016 — Terry Francona, Cleveland Indians
    2017 — Paul Molitor, Minnesota Twins
    2018 — Bob Melvin, Oakland Athletics
    2019 — Rocco Baldelli, Minnesota Twins
    2020 — Kevin Cash, Tampa Bay Rays

    2021 — Kevin Cash, Tampa Bay Rays
    2022 — Terry Francona, Cleveland Guardians
    2023 — Brandon Hyde, Baltimore Orioles
    2024 — Stephen Vogt, Cleveland Guardians
    2025 — Stephen Vogt, Cleveland Guardians