Could Javonte Williams' return hamstring the Cowboys' defensive upgrades? Unpacking the steep price tag and questionable long-term value.
The Dallas Cowboys appear interested in bringing back running back Javonte Williams, and the feeling is reportedly mutual. On the surface, it makes sense.
Williams was productive, reliable in pass protection, and familiar with Dallas’ offensive system. But as discussed on the latest episode of The Dallas Cowboys Daily Blitz Podcast LIVE, re-signing Williams may not be the straightforward decision it seems, especially if the price climbs.
Podcast host Timm Hamm cautioned that the Cowboys must avoid paying for comfort instead of upside.
“Bringing Javonte back could be smart,” Hamm said. “But it could also be the kind of move that looks fine in March and feels like a cap mistake by Thanksgiving.”
Williams gave Dallas stability in 2025, but the Cowboys are facing an offseason where stability alone may not be enough. With major contracts looming and a defense in need of multiple upgrades, every dollar matters.
Hamm emphasized that running back is one of the most replaceable positions in the NFL, making overpayment especially dangerous.
“You don’t pay premium dollars for ‘stable’ at running back unless he’s changing games,” Hamm said. “And that’s where the line has to be drawn.”
Market projections suggest Williams could command close to $9–10 million per season. According to Hamm, that number should be a hard stop.
“If Javonte’s price gets anywhere near ten million a year, I’m out,” he said. “That’s money better spent fixing real problems on this roster.”
Those problems largely reside on defense. Dallas must address linebacker depth, pass rush consistency, and overall flexibility under a new defensive coordinator.
Hamm argued that committing too much money to Williams would limit the Cowboys’ ability to improve where it matters most.
“Dallas doesn’t need to run it back,” Hamm said. “They need to level up.”
The alternative, Hamm noted, is a disciplined approach ... a short-term, team-friendly deal for Williams or a pivot toward a cheaper veteran paired with a draft pick. The Cowboys have already proven they can find production without overspending at running back.
Ultimately, Hamm made it clear the issue isn’t Williams himself, it’s the cost.
“Offer him a fair deal that works for both sides,” Hamm said. “But if the number climbs, let someone else pay for the nostalgia.”
For a franchise trying to move from good to great, restraint may be the smartest play of all.