
The New Orleans Saints offense, led by rookie quarterback Tyler Shough, faces a critical NFC South matchup against the Carolina Panthers this Sunday. Based on the film and the first meeting between these two rivals, the formula for New Orleans is clear, run the football effectively and let Shough's mobility keep the Panthers' aggressive 3-4 defense off balance.
Carolina’s defensive identity is built on the personnel of a 3-4 scheme that has recently invested heavily in the defensive line. The return of superstar defensive tackle Derrick Brown this season, alongside additions like Tershawn Wharton and Bobby Brown III, has drastically improved a run defense that struggled last year. They are no longer a pushover, but they are not impenetrable, either.
The absolute priority for New Orleans must be establishing the running game.
Exploit the Edge and Linebackers: The Panthers' defensive strength is their interior defensive line, but their overall rushing defense still ranks in the middle of the pack (17th in yards allowed per game). The Saints found success last week with a ground-heavy attack, logging 139 yards against Tampa Bay, with rookie RB Devin Neal and Shough combining for the bulk of the production. While they will miss Alvin Kamara, the Saints' offensive line has shown it can be effective. They must use misdirection, outside zone runs, and play-action to attack the second level and wear down linebackers like Christian Rozeboom.
Neutralize the Anchor (Derrick Brown): Brown is a game-wrecker. Center Luke Fortner and the guards must have a consistent plan for double-teaming or passing off Brown to prevent him from blowing up running plays in the backfield. If the Saints cannot run the ball early, the entire offense will falter.
Tyler Shough's ability to create outside of the pocket is the perfect counterpunch to Carolina's pass rush.
Extend the Play: Carolina has struggled to generate pressure this season, ranking near the bottom in sacks (29th last year, improving but not dominant this year). However, a rookie quarterback can often hold the ball too long, inviting pressure. Shough must use his legs to extend plays, not just to scramble for yardage (though his 55 rushing yards last week were invaluable), but to give play-makers like Chris Olave time to get open downfield.
Target the Secondary: The Panthers' secondary features Pro Bowler Jaycee Horn and the versatile safety Tre'von Moehrig. In the first meeting, Shough had a strong passing day (282 yards, two TDs), and Olave managed a 100-yard day. This suggests that despite the talent in the secondary, there are opportunities for one-on-one matchups on the outside. Shough should trust Olave and other receivers to win those isolated routes, particularly after a run-heavy approach softens the defense.
Despite a successful first meeting where the Saints' defense dominated, the offense cannot get complacent.
Turnovers: The Panthers' defense thrives on takeaways (ranked 10th in turnovers forced). Shough is still a young quarterback who can be prone to mistakes, and Carolina's safeties, including Moehrig, are active in coverage. Protecting the ball against a divisional opponent eager to force a turnover and swing the momentum will be crucial.
Panthers' Red Zone Defense: While Carolina's overall scoring defense is average (15th), they can tighten up in the red zone. The Saints' offense, which already ranks in the bottom third of the league in points scored (30th), needs to execute flawlessly inside the 20 to avoid settling for field goals.
The Saints' 3-10 record is misleading when looking at their recent form and the divisional nature of this game. New Orleans has a clear path to victory, and it runs right through the Carolina front seven.
The Saints must be physical, deliberate, and opportunistic. Run the ball to set up the pass, use Shough's mobility to buy time for shots to Olave, and absolutely avoid the costly turnovers that have plagued the team this season. If the Saints control the clock and keep the Panthers' defense on the field, a low-scoring, but satisfying, home victory is well within reach.