Opinion Discussion

 profile image
Create new post
JohnDenton555@RoundtableIO profile image
John DentonAug 21, 2026

Is 2026 a Lost Season for Veteran Right-Hander George Kirby?

Just when it looked like veteran right-hander George Kirby was on the path to turning his season around with two strong starts in early August, the bottom appeared to fall out on the Mariners' starter over the last six days.

Kirby shut out the Twins over seven innings on Aug. 2 and limited the Rays to just one earned run in five innings of work on Aug. 8. The hope was that the 28-year-old right-hander was regaining the form that made him a dependable starter in 2025 in the AL Division Series win.

JohnDenton555@RoundtableIO profile image
John DentonAug 20, 2026

Could a Healthy Brendan Donovan be Key to Playoff Push for Ms?

For much of this season, the Mariners have been unable to see the positive effects that Brendan Donovan can have on a lineup because of the groin injury that cost him half of May and all of June and July.

Finally healthy, Donovan is starting to show the impact he can have on a lineup with his contagious energy and gritty style of play.

mrseahawk13@RoundtableIO profile image
mrseahawk13Aug 12, 2026

Michael Rucker?

I’m not about asking for a man’s job either, but how can we abide by bringing Michael Rucker into a 1-0 game on the first day of a road trip that will determine the fate of the season? How could we be even a bit surprised that the two lefties leading off the inning smoked balls into right. If I didn’t know better, I’d swear Wilson was selling the season. This move made no sense on any level.

1
SamPhalen@RoundtableIO profile image
Sam PhalenJul 27, 2026

Would you accept this trade?

I think the Chicago White Sox are a really good fit for Mariners starting pitcher Luis Castillo at this year's deadline. 

Some thoughts below on the match for both teams and a potential trade package. 

JasonBurke@RoundtableIO profile image
Jason BurkeJul 21, 2026

Ready For October?

The Mariners hold a slim half-game lead over the Texas Rangers in an awful AL West, but Seattle has arguably underperformed all season and is still the only club in the division with a positive run differential (+21). 

How close are the Mariners to actually competing in the American League this postseason? What is the one trade you would make to get them to the World Series? 

SamPhalen@RoundtableIO profile image
Sam PhalenJul 16, 2026

A smart Mariners deadline approach

The Mariners may trade from their starting pitching depth to get more talent elsewhere. 

Would be a smart take on the trade deadline given the current landscape in the American League. The offense needs serious help and someone like Castillo is expendable at this point. 

JohnDenton555@RoundtableIO profile image
John DentonJul 15, 2026

Randy Arozarena an all-time Mariners player now as a multiple-time All-Star?

A year after Mariners stars played major roles in the MLB All-Star Game, Randy Arozarena with the club's only participant in Tuesday night's Midsummer Classic -- a 4-0 win for the AL over the NL.

The two teams combined for just seven hits, 27 strikeouts and just one extra-base hit in a game that featured only one run scored after the first inning.

JohnDenton555@RoundtableIO profile image
John DentonMay 12, 2026

Is the WBC to Blame for Cal Raleigh's Dismal Start to 2026?

Some of the best hitters in baseball -- Mariners slugger Cal Raleigh, Bryce Harper, Juan Soto, Fernando Tatis Jr., Alex Bregman, Ronald Acuna Jr., Gunnar Henderson, Will Smith and Pete Crow-Armstrong -- have gotten off to uncharacteristically poor starts so far in 2026.

Also, elite pitchers such as Tarik Skubal, Edwin Diaz, Brayan Bello, Yusei Kikuchi and Daniel Palencia have struggled with either performance, injury issues or both early this season.

JohnDenton555@RoundtableIO profile image
John DentonMay 10, 2026

Will the Return of Bryce Miller Help Mariners Through Trying Time?

In recent years, the Mariners have almost universally been thought to have the best pitching staff in baseball. While that group has shown some cracks early this season, could the imminent return of Bryce Miller lead to the M's having a dominant starting staff again?

How they fare over one of their most arduous stretches of the season could be very telling.

JohnDenton555@RoundtableIO profile image
John DentonMay 9, 2026

Could Hall of Famer Edgar Martinez be Behind Luke Raley's Power Surge?

An absolute genius as a hitter, Edgar Martinez might have just given the Mariners' struggling offense just the lift it needed yet again.

With Luke Raley mired in a month-long slump in April -- and his hot, three-homer start in March a distant memory -- the struggling outfielder sought out the counsel of Seattle's resident Hall of Fame designated hitter, per MLB.com's Jackson Stone.

1
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy