Stephenson Could Fill Angels' Gaping Hole At Catcher
Nov 17, 2026 4:25 PM

Former Cincinnati Red Tyler Stephenson is one of the most-coveted free-agent backstops and Los Angeles should be willing to consider him as an answer to their catching woes.

You'll have to forgive Los Angeles Angels' fans if seeing or hearing the name "Stephenson" causes their PTSD to kick in; you know, Post-Traumatic "Stephenson" Disorder.

That's because the Angels have just rid themselves of the nightmare that was the three-year, $33-million contract they signed with relief pitcher Robert Stephenson before the 2024 season.

In the three seasons from 2024-26, the Angels got a grand total of 10 innings (all in 2025) out of Stephenson as he was beset by injuries, starting with Tommy John surgery in May of 2024 and concluding with surgery on a damaged ligament and flexor tendon in his right elbow, which kept him out of action for the entire 2026 season.

But that dark chapter in Los Angeles' checkered free-agent history is now closed and it's time to consider another Stephenson as the answer to another one of the Angels' long-time roster dilemmas: free-agent catcher Tyler Stephenson, late of the Cincinnati Reds.

Related stories

With the trade of Logan O'Hoppe to the Texas Rangers in the summer and the expiring of Travis d'Arnaud's contract following the 2026 season, the Angels currently have two catchers on their 40-man roster.

Moises Ballesteros, who they acquired from the Chicago Cubs at the trade deadline, has the most promise and is expected by some to build off an overall promising rookie season. After experiencing some growing pains immediately following the trade (.163 average and a .410 OPS over 24 games) he appeared to become better acclimated in September (.708 OPS in 21 games with three homers and eight RBIs).

The one possible hiccup with Ballesteros becoming a full-time catcher is that he is not a good defender behind the plate, something that both the Cubs and Angels have appeared to notice as his 113 major-league appearances in 2025-26 have seen him play 30 games behind the plate and 83 as a designated hitter.

After Ballesteros, however, the cupboard is nearly completely bare with Logan Porter the only other catcher currently on the 40-man roster and his MLB experience encompasses a grand total of 18 games played for three organizations since 2023. The Angels did resign Mike Heineman to a one-year deal on Nov. 13, but with a .175 average and 10 RBIs in 2026, he's nothing more than a depth piece.

All of which should make it obvious that the Angels have to at least kick the tires on T. Stephenson.

While he's not spectacular (how many catchers really are these days?), Stephenson is a solid pro who's typically been able to answer the bell consistently; he has four seasons of 130 or more games sandwiched around injury-marred 2022 (50 games) and 2025 (88 games) seasons.

What you'll get when he does play is a catcher who has proven to provide, per 162-game averages, 18 home runs, 73 RBIs and 27 doubles with a .257 average, .757 OPS and 104 OPS+, all of which equates to a solid, for a catcher, 2.5 WAR. Also, while he'll never be a Gold Glover, his defensive work is passable as far as a pitch-blocker, while he was successful in 2026 in overturning calls more often than not via the ABS challenge system.

If the Angels do pursue Stephenson, his price should be reasonable: a two- to three-year commitment with an average annual salary that could creep into the low $10 millions.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy