Bleacher Report Suggests One Interesting Trade Idea For Astros

The Houston Astros have some key decisions to make when it comes to building out this roster for the upcoming season, and that could look like being aggressive in free agency or through trades.

On that note, Bleacher Report has suggested a trade idea for the Astros that may be unpopular for Houston and the fanbase in particular. Recently, Bleacher Report MLB analyst Tim Kelly pitched 5 unpopular MLB offseason trade ideas, and for the Astros, Kelly suggested they should trade shortstop Jeremy Pena to the Toronto Blue Jays.

Ultimately, there could be several reasons why this trade may or may not happen, but one point from Kelly did stick out which was the fact that owner Jim Crane has opted to trade star players who Houston does not intended extending prior to when that player is in their contract year.

One example Kelly mentioned was when the Astros traded outfielder Kyle Tucker to the Chicago Cubs two winters ago before the final year of arbitration. With that said, it is worth wondering if that could happen again.

Now, looking briefly on the Blue Jays side, they had a tough 2026 campaign as Toronto went 79-83 in the AL East, so adding a player like Pena could be huge for the Blue Jays to be able to take a least a solid step forward on defense, but also at the plate.

Getting back to the situation with Pena and the Astros, this idea is not necessarily a surprise as this idea has been floated around throughout the offseason thus far, especially because shortstop Carlos Correa is expected to be back for Houston after missing most of the 2026 season due to injury.

That said, that does put Pena in an interesting position when it comes to earning a spot in the rotation because he had a solid year in 2026, however, a veteran like Correa who has the experience he has does make this situation a lot more complex.

Additionally, the fact that the Astros have Randy Flores coming in to be the next general manager as well as just recently hiring Brad Ausmus to be the next manager will also play a major role as to whether or not Pena is traded because Flores has a major say in the roster overall and Ausmus has to figure out how to maximize the talent on this roster and figure out whether or not Pena fits into his vision.

So, as the Astros move forward throughout this offseason, it will be interesting to monitor Pena's situation and see if they want to extend him and keep him around or if Flores, Ausmus, and Crane agree that it is time to move on from Pena and trade him away to acquire draft capital, young talent, or a veteran player who could come in and contribute right away.

Regardless of what does happen with Pena, this will be an interesting situation to watch for Houston this offseason.

More From Astros Roundtable:

ESPN Analyst Grades His Preseason Prediction For Astros

Bleacher Report Ranks 3 Astros Free Agents in the Top 50

Did the Astros Make a Mistake Hiring Brad Ausmus as Manager?

Yordan Alvarez Makes Astros History With Unanimous MVP Win