Nov 16, 2026 4:28 AM
If the A's decided to trade Shea Langeliers, the New York Yankees would make an intriguing trade partner.
There have been no reports that the new Athletics front office is considering trading All-Star catcher Shea Langeliers, but there could come a point when an extension is essentially off the table and the team needs to start thinking about getting the most value for him to ensure the club's long-term success.
Of course, Langeliers could also sign an extension.
Today, let's take a look at what a package could look like for a potential deal and get your opinion on whether or not the A's should make the trade.
Putting Together a Shea Langeliers Trade
Langeliers, 28, has really started to put things together the past two seasons, hitting a combined .270 with a .326 OBP and a 125 OPS+ (100 is league average), and he has been a top-5 offensive catcher in MLB the past two seasons.
Related stories
His trade value is pretty high right now, though it could be hampered slightly by his numbers after his return from surgery. He hit just .250 with a .294 OBP and zero home runs across 13 September games, good for a 58 wRC+. Of course, he was fresh off surgery for a torn meniscus in his right knee, so it's understandable that he wasn't firing on all cylinders.
It just goes into the trade calculation is all.
The Yankees specifically make some sense for the A's as a trade partner, given some of the team's needs. They also have a terrific defensive catcher in Austin Wells, who has one more season of team control than Langeliers, and could see an uptick in offensive production playing in West Sacramento.
In 2025, he hit 21 home runs, but those same balls would have left the yard 29 times if every game were played in West Sacramento. That trend didn't continue in 2026, when he would have hit one fewer home run playing in California than he did with New York.
Wells would be the first piece, serving as the big-league replacement for Langeliers. He's a career .213 hitter with a .294 OBP, and he held just a 77 wRC+ this past season, but the A's could use upgrades defensively, and can afford to lose one bat in the lineup. The question is whether they can afford to lose Langeliers' bat specifically, given that he helped carry the team in the early going in 2026.
Wells ranked in the 92nd percentile in blocking and the 95th percentile in framing. He wasn't as good with his pop time (23rd percentile) and caught stealing (15th percentile), but the ability to block and frame pitches would provide a huge boost to the developing A's pitching staff.
The second piece would likely need to be an addition to the rotation, and Will Warren would make a lot of sense for the A's. He's under team control through 2030, giving them four seasons of the right-hander, and he also fits the mold of the skills they're after. Warren held a 3.92 ERA (3.94 FIP) in 2026 while boasting a 44.2% ground-ball rate and an 8% walk rate.
Both of those would play in West Sacramento, or any hitter's park. Warren is also on the outside of the Yankee rotation looking in, making him a depth arm that New York shouldn't mind letting go too much.
The final piece could go in a number of directions, and with the A's new front office, it's tough to get a read on where they would go just yet. They could target a position player to give them depth, perhaps as a defensive upgrade somewhere else around the diamond. They could also try to lure an underperforming player like Jasson Domínguez away from the Bronx, but given the package thus far, that may be more difficult.
One prospect that makes sense for the A's would be Ben Hess, who is ranked as New York's No. 5 prospect according to MLB Pipeline. The 24-year-old right-hander has reached Double-A, and won't need to be on the 40-man roster until after the 2027 season, which provides a little more roster flexibility with the A's roster.
Hess has a big 60-grade curveball and cutter combo while his fastball tops out at 98, but sits more mid-90s. He would definitely be a work in progress for the A's, but with the renewed organizational emphasis on pitching development, they may be able to reach that ceiling.
All in all, we'd likely be looking at Austin Wells and a couple of other pieces in return for Langeliers. Warren makes sense as someone the A's could insert directly into their rotation, while Hess is for the future of the staff. The front office could see the roster a little differently and decide to go in another direction entirely, but the valuation of the trade would be close to where we ended up.
2
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


