
The Toronto Blue Jays made a surprising trade on Friday morning, acquiring slugging outfielder Jesus Sanchez from the Houston Astros.
Sanchez, a six-year veteran, has real power and should help alleviate the loss of Anthony Santander, who could be out the entire season with a labrum injury. Sanchez has five straight seasons of double-digit home runs, including 18 in 2024.
He also doesn't strike out a ton (22 percent in 2025), meaning he'll fit in with the Jays' blend of power and contact.
But while his addition is exciting, it also poses some trouble for Nathan Lukes, who was an integral part of the 2025 campaign.
Let's dive in.
C: Alejandro Kirk
1B: Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
2B: Ernie Clement
SS: Andres Gimenez
3B: Kazuma Okamoto
RF: Addison Barger
CF: Daulton Varsho
LF: Jesus Sanchez
DH: George Springer
Bench 1: Tyler Heineman
Bench 2: Davis Schneider
Bench 3: Myles Straw
Bench 4: ??
1) This bench doesn't have a true utility bench infielder on its roster. Schneider can play the infield, but he isn't really a suitable "jack-of-all-trades" infielder at this point in his career, is he? He has played just four big-league games at third base and has never played one at shortstop.
2) Is the team satisfied with Ernie Clement as its backup shortstop? He's projected as a starter, but he does have 87 career games there under his belt, including 29 last season. If they are content with Schneider and Clement to handle those duties, then there's still a chance that "Bench 4" could go to Lukes.
3) Are the Jays ready to bench Okamoto against right-handed pitching? They just spent $60 million on him so it seems doubtful, but if they were, they'd be able to play Barger at third and use Lukes in right more often.
4) Of course, there's a chance they could keep Lukes on the roster and just acknowledge that the roster doesn't quite work the way they'd want it to. They could still find time for Lukes, but it would be more sparse if he's in a timeshare with Sanchez.
5) They could trade Lukes in order to bring in a piece that fits better now.
A 31-year-old, Lukes saw significant time in 2025, hitting .255 with 12 homers in 388 at-bats. He also posted 65 RBIs, showcasing some power and run-producing ability. He was a regular starter in the playoffs, appearing in 17 of 18 possible games, hitting .274 with eight RBIs.
Remember to join our BLUE JAYS on ROUNDTABLE community, which is FREE! You can post your own thoughts, in text or video form, and you can engage with our Roundtable staff, as well as other Blue Jays fans. If prompted to download the Roundtable APP, that's free too!