Should the Atlanta Braves Trade Spencer Strider?

The Atlanta Braves have a difficult decision to make with Spencer Strider this offseason. His future in Atlanta is far from guaranteed, and the club is certainly open to trading him. However, selling him now would likely mean selling low.

The 27-year-old right-hander is coming off another injury-shortened season, and his value is way below what it could be if he returns to form in 2027.

Strider finished 2026 with a 4-2 record, a 5.31 ERA and 46 strikeouts across 39 innings. He made just eight total starts due to right elbow inflammation. He was sent to the injured list in June and ultimately did not make a return. It was the third straight year injuries derailed his season.

There is definitely a strong case for moving him. Strider has now had three disrupted seasons, and Atlanta would be taking a real risk by counting on him to return as a reliable starter.

He is also owed $22 million in 2027, so trading him could free up salary for other offseason moves. If the Braves believe he is not capable of staying healthy, moving on might be safer than carrying that uncertainty into another year. 

Strider's trade value is likely at its lowest right now, after an injury-shortened year in which he struggled when he was actually available. Atlanta would be selling before he has had a chance to show he can get back to his previous level.

Any team acquiring him would also have to weigh the same medical and performance questions, making a valuable prospect return unlikely.

The Braves can afford to be patient. They finished 94-68 and won the National League East despite Strider missing most of the season. His contract also runs through 2028 with a club option for 2029, so Atlanta is not facing any immediate deadline.

Strider's ceiling is the biggest reason to hold. In 2023, he went 20-5 with a 3.86 ERA and led the NL with 281 strikeouts. He has not been able to match that level since and his velocity has dipped, though.

There is a ton of risk and if he is moved the Braves would likely be on the hook for some of his contract. Trading him now would mean accepting a reduced return while giving another club the upside if he rebounds. Unless Atlanta receives an offer that reflects what Strider can be at his best, keeping him and reassessing after a healthy 2027 is the smarter play.