Why Putting Off Contreras’ Extension Could Cost Brewers Long Term
Nov 17, 2026 9:30 PM

Although the Milwaukee Brewers picked up star catcher William Contreras’ option, they should look to get a deal done quickly.

The Milwaukee Brewers should re-sign William Contreras as soon as possible.More Videos

It has been an interesting start to the offseason for the Milwaukee Brewers.

The World Series champions have lost Dustin May to the Chicago White Sox and JoJo Romero, who is attracting interest from multiple teams.

This comes after they already lost their first baseman and National League Championship Series MVP Jake Bauers to the Boston Red Sox early in the offseason.

The defending champions managed to bring back star catcher and World Series MVP William Contreras after exercising his $15.5 million option for the 2027 season.

Related stories

However, the long-term commitment remains uncertain because Contreras could enter free agency after the option expires.

This emphasizes the importance of making it a priority for the Brewers to bring back the three-time all-star for the long term.

Milwaukee shouldn’t wait to extend Contreras

While it's been reported that the Brewers are interested in reaching a long-term deal, it's still important that they maintain a sense of urgency to secure Contreras' future with the team.

Over the past couple of seasons, the catcher has been part of the Brewers' core. It has become one of the best teams in the league since he joined the team in 2023, thanks to his consistent production.

Over 593 games, Milwaukee is 360-233 all-time with Contreras in the lineup, underscoring his undeniable impact. 

Not every player who is individually great can also be impactful to the entire team. Whenever a team has a player who is capable of individual success that leads to the team performing as a whole, you have to do whatever is necessary to keep them.

Also, prolonging contract talks can be frustrating for any player, especially after a great season and capping it off with a World Series MVP.

Why Brewers may not be in hurry for an extension

There could many different reasons as to why contract talks stall.

Most of the time, it comes from sides not being able to agree to a number.

Other times, it could be the player wanting to take a gamble on themselves in pursuit of an even bigger deal.  

Although it can be rare, there are also times when both sides put off the conversation because they are confident a deal will be done eventually.

In this case, I think it can be a mix of both. Contreras may believe he has a much larger payday in his future after playing a significant role in the Brewers winning their first-ever title.

However, it feels that both sides may already have a number in mind, and there’s no doubt they’ll get a deal done, as it would be hard to imagine Milwaukee mishandling the star’s value.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy