Freddy Peralta’s consistency, affordability, and leadership make him a cornerstone of the Brewers’ rotation, but those same traits also boost his trade value with free agency looming.
As the Brewers look ahead to 2026, one question continues to loom larger than any other: should Milwaukee hold onto Freddy Peralta, or is now the time to cash in on one of its most valuable assets? It’s a debate that defined the start of the offseason and remains unresolved as the calendar turns, underscoring how complicated the decision truly is.
From a competitive standpoint, the argument to keep Peralta is straightforward. Few pitchers in baseball offer his blend of durability and swing-and-miss stuff. Peralta has made at least 30 starts in three consecutive seasons while consistently eclipsing the 200-strikeout mark, a level of reliability that is increasingly rare across the league. Entering the final year of team control, he is also set to earn roughly $8 million, a bargain salary for a frontline starter in today’s market. For a Brewers club that regularly competes despite operating with payroll constraints, that type of production at that price point is enormously valuable.
There is also Peralta’s importance beyond the box score. Within the clubhouse, he is viewed as a leader and a stabilizing presence, someone younger pitchers gravitate toward. Trading him would not only remove an ace from the rotation but also disrupt the internal chemistry Milwaukee has carefully cultivated over recent seasons.
At the same time, the Brewers’ organizational philosophy complicates matters. Milwaukee has rarely relied on free agency to patch major holes, instead building sustained success through smart drafting, player development, and well-timed trades. Peralta, precisely because of his performance, contract value, and reputation, fits the profile of a player who could command a significant return. Teams seeking rotation help have reportedly shown interest, and for a small-market club, ignoring that interest entirely would be uncharacteristic.
The timing is also critical. With Peralta one year away from free agency, the Brewers risk losing him for far less than his current market value if they wait too long. Trading him now could replenish the farm system or address long-term needs, helping ensure Milwaukee remains competitive beyond 2026.
Ultimately, this is a decision with real consequences on both sides. Keeping Peralta signals a commitment to contending in the near term and maintaining rotation stability. Moving him, however, could reshape the franchise’s future at the cost of immediate pain. For the Brewers, choosing between those paths may define not only their offseason, but the direction of the organization moving forward.
Join the Community#
Don't miss out on our ROUNDTABLE community and the latest news!
It's completely free to join. Share your thoughts, engage with our Roundtable writers, and chat with fellow members.
Download the free Roundtable APP, and stay even more connected!