Nov 5, 2026 11:38 PM
The Cardinals badly need a third baseman, and Alec Bohm is widely considered the best free-agent third baseman available this offseason. Here are some pros and (mostly) cons as to why the Cardinals should look elsewhere when trying to find their third baseman for 2027.
Roundtable Sports' John Denton details the many reasons why the St. Louis Cardinals should stay away from signing third baseman Alec Bohm in free agency this offseason.More Videos
The St. Louis Cardinals badly need a third baseman, and long-time Phillies standout Alec Bohm is almost universally thought of as the top third baseman available in free agency this offseason.
So, it should be a no-brainer for a Cardinals-Bohm marriage before the lockout hits on Dec. 1 and shuts down baseball, right? Well, about that …
There are plusses and negatives to almost every free-agent signing made by MLB teams, and bringing the 30-year-old Bohm to St. Louis would be chocked full of pros and cons. Let’s examine some of those pros and cons:
Pros: Bohm is a proven commodity at third base, hitting .273 with a .735 OPS and 85 home runs, 172 doubles and 493 RBI in seven seasons in Philadelphia. He finished second in the NL Rookie of the Year voting in 2020, he was an All-Star in 2024, and he’s appeared in the playoffs each of the past five seasons.
Related stories
Cons: A Phillies team in big-time need of injecting some athleticism and life into their sluggish offense declined to even make a Qualifying Offer ($23.15 million) to Bohm, and that should certainly raise some eyebrows. This past season -- .249 batting average, .698 OPS, 15 homers, 88 RBI – was one of the worst of his career. And, as 30 years old, he could register for AARP in a Cardinals clubhouse full of 20-somethings.
Pros: Bohm was born in Omaha, Neb. – home of Cardinals Hall of Famer Bob Gibson – and he went to college at Wichita State. He’s about as Midwestern as they come and he never really fit in in gritty Philadelphia, a place where he once uttered, “I (expletive) hate this place,” as Phillies fans were showering him with boos following a defensive misplay.
Cons: Busch Stadium, home to the famed “Best Fans in Baseball” would never openly boo a hometown player following an error. Instead, they would go on social media and grouse about it like any good Midwesterner would do! Playing in “Baseball Heaven” might actually bring out the untapped potential in the player picked No. 3 overall in the 2018 MLB Draft.
Pros: Over the last five seasons, Bohm has hit 13, 20, 15, 11 and 15 home runs.
Cons: Bohm did that in the bandbox known as Citizens Bank Park, where games often turn into the kind of Home Run Derbies that Cardinals slugger Jordan Walker won back in July in Philly. Over the past five years, there have been 1,022 homers at Citizens Bank Park or 204.4 homers per season on average. At Busch Stadium – a park where homers go to die – there have been just 779 homers or 155.8 long balls per season on average. This past season alone, Citizens Bank Park was home to the eighth most homers in MLB (202), while Busch Stadium was 29th in homers yielded (132).
Pros: Signing Bohm to a long-term deal would give the Cardinals their third baseman for several years to come.
Cons: Rainiel Rodriguez, the top prospect in the Cardinals system following a season where he hit .328 with 23 homers and 66 RBI in his first 87 games at Double-A at the ripe age of 19 years old, was originally signed as a third baseman and he could be seeing some reps there in the near future in the Dominican Winter League. The same goes for Jesus Baez, who hit 39 homers at High-A Peoria and Double-A Springfield and two more in the playoffs. Signing Bohm would effectively block those top prospects’ paths to the big leagues.
Pros: St. Louis has a proud history of strong defensive third basemen, with Ken Boyer (five Gold Gloves), Terry Pendleton (three Gold Gloves), Hall of Famer Scott Rolen (eight Gold Gloves) and Nolan Arenado (10 Gold Gloves) setting the standard at the hot corner.
Cons: There’s little chance that Bohm will be racking up any defensive hardware at third base any time soon. This past season, Bohm ranked 38th among all MLB third basemen in Outs Above Average (minus-8) and 175th in Defensive Runs Saved (minus-10). In terms of range, the 6-foot-4 Bohm was in MLB’s 2nd percentile (minus-11) and his arm strength (79.8 mph) would look like an underhanded lob when compared to that of Cardinals shortstop Masyn Winn (94.4 mph).
Pro: Signing Bohm would give the Cardinals two corner infielders named Alec.
Con: The Gateway to the West might only be big enough for one Alec, the one who led MLB in RBI this past season with 116.
Pros: The Cardinals definitely should sign a Phillies free agent this offseason as a stopgap player at third base until Rodriguez or Baez are ready for the big leagues.
Cons: However, that former Phillie should be Edmundo Sosa and not Bohm. Sosa, who signed with the Cardinals out of Panama and played for the franchise from 2018-22, had a significantly better WAR (1.0) than Bohm (minus-0.2) in 2026. Sosa, 30, could likely be signed to a one-year, budget-friendly deal, allowing the Cards to spend their cash on starting pitching and relief help. Another perk: They would no longer have to face Sosa, who had a key hit in Philadelphia’s Game 1 playoff win over the Cardinals in 2022 and went 6 for 11 with three doubles and eight RBI against St. Louis in 2026.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


