Nov 18, 2026 1:00 PM
Chase Davis, the No. 21 overall pick of the 2023 MLB Draft, was not protected by the St. Louis Cardinals prior to Tuesday's deadline, meaning another MLB club can select him in the Rule 5 Draft. For whatever reason, Davis has been unable to unlock the power he flashed in high school and college.
Roundtable Sports' John Denton breaks down the St. Louis Cardinals choice to leave 2023 first-round pick Chase Davis unprotected with the Rule 5 Draft coming up.More Videos
On the heels of the St. Louis Cardinals leaving him unprotected and vulnerable to being poached by another MLB franchise in the Rule 5 Draft, Chase Davis must wonder what lies ahead in a baseball journey already full of twists and turns.
One of the nation’s top high school players in 2020, Davis shockingly went undrafted that year when the COVID-19 pandemic shortened the draft to five rounds and teams sided mostly with collegiate players they had already scouted for years.
That led Davis to the University of Arizona, where he struggled adapting to the college game and failed to homer as a freshman in 27 games. Familiarity seemed to help over the next two seasons as Davis slubbed 18 and 21 homers and put himself in prime position for the 2023 MLB Draft.
A Cardinals franchise in desperate need of outfielders with pop selected the 6-foot-1, 216-pound Davis with the No. 21 pick – a selection made former St. Louis assistant general manager and current Houston Astros GM Randy Flores. Could Flores look to bring Davis to Houston where the Astros led all of MLB in home runs with 226 in 2026?
Related stories
Soon after drafting Davis back in 2023, the Cards brought him to St. Louis where he signed his first pro deal and then put on a show in batting practice with some tape-measure blasts into the empty bleachers at Busch Stadium. It was a familiar sight to Cardinals youngsters Jordan Walker and Masyn Winn, who had played in the youth baseball circuits with and against Davis, who had built a reputation as someone with a rare blend of power and speed.
A few weeks later, Davis was suiting up for Class-A Palm Beach, and even though he was facing many players younger than him, he failed to homer in 34 games that first pro season. By 2024, Davis’s bat started to come alive again, and that got him promoted from Class-A Palm Beach to High-A Peoria and Double-A Springfield. In 2025, he was a part of the Springfield team that won the Texas League title, but by then JJ Wetherholt, Joshua Baez and Leo Bernal had passed him by as prospects because of his unremarkable season in Double-A.
Ranked as the No. 6 prospect in the Cardinals’ Minor League system in 2023 and ’24, Davis dropped to No. 10 by 2025 and all the way out of the Top 30 in 2026.
The Sacramento, Calif., native showed off his enormous potential by hitting two home runs in an MLB Spring Training game against the Orioles on March 9. He hit eight homers in his first 37 games at Double-A Springfield this past season, but his momentum was slowed by a month on the Injured List and another two weeks of rehabilitation assignments.
He played 50 games with Triple-A Memphis and had six home runs and six doubles, but his strikeouts (52) dwarfed his walks (22). He homered in his third game with the Redbirds but then went 16 games without a long ball. He went into the playoffs with some momentum with two homers in his last four games of the regular season. However, he went just 1 for 12 in three postseason games and did not register an extra-base hit.
Through 352 career games in the Minor Leagues, Davis’s batting average (.239) and OPS (.731) have fallen short of what the Cardinals thought possible, and he’s never topped 15 home runs. That’s what led to the Cardinals passing him over in favor of Double-A infielder Jesús Báez and High-A pitching prospect Jacob Odle, both of whom were added to the club’s 40-man roster on Tuesday. As for Davis, time will tell if he ever plays another game in the Cardinals system again or if he is poached by another organization curious to see if it can unlock his untapped power.
1
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


