Jul 29, 2026 7:58 PM

Several MLB teams are on the hunt for catching and Cardinals backup backstop Pedro Pagés might make an appealing target considering that he is tied for first in MLB with 14 base stealers thrown out in 2026. Should the Cards deal him with the throwing struggles of Ivan Herrera and Jimmy Crooks?

Roundtable Sports' John Denton wonders if Pedro Pagés might be the Cardinals' most coveted trade chip because of the need for catching and his strong arm behind the plate.More Videos

Loved by teammates for his peppy personality, respected by the pitching staff because of his tireless prep work and his ability to control the running game, but often jeered by fans who deride him for the lack of pop in his bat, Pedro Pagés presents an interesting case study for the Cardinals at the MLB Trade Deadline.

Pagés could be one of the Cardinals on the move before the Aug. 3 MLB Trade Deadline because of the numerous teams in need of solid catching down the stretch. The Dodgers, Yankees, Red Sox, Rays, White Sox and Rangers are in need in catching and the Cardinals – a team with a glut of catchers at the MLB level and in their Minor League system – could be a fit as a trade partner.

Pages, 27, is a career .227 hitter with 22 long balls over three seasons, but what could potentially make him attractive to playoff-bound teams is his ability to control the running game. Despite being a part-time catcher most of this season after rookie Jimmy Crooks was elevated from Triple-A Memphis, Pagés is tied for the MLB lead in baserunners caught stealing (14) with Orioles’ standout backstop Adley Rutschman.

Arm Strength (81.3 mph) and average pop time (1.91 seconds) rank near the middle of the league, but Pagés has been able to throw out 34 percent of all base stealers this season with smooth transitions, good footwork and accurate throws. Pagés’ caught-stealing percentage is easily better than the MLB average of 29 percent, making him especially appealing to teams with World Series aspirations.

Related stories

The Cardinals fell below .500 for the first time all season on Tuesday night when they lost 10-2 to the rival Cubs. A feel-good surprise most of the season, the Cards have dropped 15 of their last 21 games and nine of 12 since the break for the MLB All-Star Game to fall out of the chase for a Wild Card slot. They host the Cubs again at 6:45 p.m. CT. 

With the Cardinals playing in a division with Elly De La Cruz, Pete Crow Armstrong and Oneil Cruz, can they afford to trade away Pagés considering the troubles that Ivan Herrera and Crooks have had throwing out base stealers this season? Herrera hasn’t thrown out a runner in 21 tries this season and his last caught stealing came in September of 2024 when Juan Soto was still a Yankee and he got mowed down while trying to swipe second against the Cardinals All-Star DH/catcher.

At issue for Herrera – who underwent arthroscopic surgery to remove loose bodies from his right elbow – is the strength of his throwing arm. Herrera’s throws to second base average just 77.2 mph, which ranks 56th in MLB, per Baseball Savant.  

As for Crooks, the Cardinals’ Minor League Player of the Year in 2024, he has yet to throw out a runner in six tries this season. Crooks’ throws to second base have been clocked at 82.3 mph on average, per Baseball Savant.

Herrera hasn't committed an error, has staff's best ERA

Herrera hasn’t committed an error, doesn’t have a passed ball and pitchers have posted a 3.86 ERA when in his 40 games behind the plate. Cardinals’ hurlers Crooks have a 4.11 ERA in the 29 games that Crooks has caught, but the rookie has a throwing error and four passed balls. As for Pagés, he has five errors and three passed balls in 58 gamers.   

    

In his third MLB seasons, Pagés has slashed just .207/.348/.327/.575 with four homers and 11 RBI in 60 games. Last season, he smashed 15 doubles and 11 homers in 112 games, but he struck out 107 times compared to just 19 walks while hitting at the bottom of the order.

Another reason why the Cardinals might consider trading Pagés, Herrera or Crooks: Two of their top five prospects in the Minor Leagues are catchers.

Rainiel Rodriguez, the second-youngest position player in Double-A at 19 years old, is the top-rated prospect in the organization and No. 12 in MLB. The 5-foot-10, 197-pound Rodriguez is hitting .273 with an .817 OPS with 11 doubles, nine homers and 31 RBI in 53 games at Double-A Springfield.

Leonardo Bernal, 22, is a native of Panama City, Panama – just like Herrera. The No. 5-ranked prospect in the system has 13 homers, 17 doubles and 61 RBI in 79 games with Triple-A Memphis this season.   

Rodriguez has seven errors and two passed balls and he’s thrown out 26.6 percent of base stealers in Double-A. Bernal has nine errors behind the plate and four passed balls and he’s thrown out just 24.6 percent of base stealers.

 

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy