Nov 17, 2026 7:08 PM

When Dustin May agreed to a three-year, $52.5 million contract with the Chicago White Sox on Tuesday, it might have helped the Cardinals. St. Louis signed May to a one-year deal for 2026 and allowed him to rebuild his value and stay healthy -- something that might appeal to other veteran pitchers.

Roundtable Sports' John Denton breaks down how Dustin May's signing with the White Sox could help the Cardinals' attempts to lure another veteran starting pitcher to St. Louis. More Videos

From the St. Louis Cardinals’ perspective, there are two ways they could choose to look at Dustin May’s signing of a $52.5 million, three-year contract with the Chicago White Sox on Tuesday.

One way to view the deal is to lament the fact that May – who had 10 Quality Starts among his 21 starts with the Cardinals in 2026 before being traded to the Milwaukee Brewers – is no longer available to potentially sign another short-term deal with St. Louis.

The other way is to view May’s signing with the White Sox is that it is a walking billboard, of sorts, for the Cardinals and their ability to resurrect the careers of veteran pitchers – something that might actually help them land another veteran starting pitcher in need of opportunity this offseason.

May, 29, signed with St. Louis after having battled various injuries earlier in his career – something that lowered his value around MLB and made him affordable for the rebuilding Cardinals. During his time in St. Louis, the Cardinals worked with him to shorten his outings when things got rocky during games, they sporadically used a six-man rotation to keep pitchers fresh and they agreed to skip one of May’s starts after he got shelled in two innings of work in Kansas City on June 21 and started having back pain.

Related stories

Then, even though May went 0-1 with five no decisions in July, the Cardinals traded the veteran pitcher to a desirable location where he was able to win another World Series ring with the Brewers. May then parlayed that into the payday he had been hoping to get years earlier – something the Cardinals could at least partially take credit for because of how they helped May avoid injuries while showcasing his abilities as a starter in 2026.

Other MLB veteran pitchers undoubtedly will take notice of May’s path to a big payday – one that started in St. Louis with a Cardinals franchise that has been great at keeping starters healthy. Andre Pallante, who missed three weeks in late August and early September with right elbow irritation, is the only Cardinals starter to go on the Injured List with an arm injury over the past two seasons.

Here is a look at other veteran starting pitchers who could look to the Cardinals as a team that could help them rebuild their worth during the 2027 season:  

Jack Flaherty

A familiar face to Cards fans, the 31-year-old right-hander spent the first six-plus seasons in St. Louis and at one time looked like a staff ace and a $100 million pitcher before injuring his arm. Having spent recent years rebuilding his value across various stops, a one-year, prove-it reunion with the Cards makes a lot of sense for both team and pitcher.

Shane Bieber

The former Cy Young winner, who made 11 starts with the Blue Jays last season as he worked his way back from elbow surgery, represents the exact type of high-upside, short-term gamble that rebuilding teams like the Cardinals look for. While he commands a premium pedigree, Bieber’s recent health timeline could align with a “one-plus-one” contract to re-establish his value before testing the market again in 2028.

Michael Lorenzen

Lorenzen would be a classic buy-low candidate – as in 3-13 with a 7.21 ERA low in 2026. He offers multi-role flexibility, durability, and veteran leadership, making him an ideal depth piece to anchor the back end of a rotation or step in as a bridge for younger arms.

Jordan Montgomery

Montgomery, now 33, was a Cardinal teammate of Flaherty’s in 2022-23 before he was traded to the Texas Rangers where he won a World Series ring. After navigating some injury-interrupted and volatile stretches, a short-term, bounce-back contract would allow Montgomery to potentially stabilize his stock while eating valuable regular-season innings.

Kyle Freeland

As durable, experienced left-hander who handles a heavy workload and generates soft contact, Freeland might find more success at pitcher-friendly Busch Stadium. A one-year pact for the 33-year-old Freeland would give St. Louis steady veteran starts every fifth day without clogging the path for Triple-A hopefuls Tekoah Roby, Jurrangelo Cijntje or Mason Molina knocking on the MLB door.

1
Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy