Jun 6, 2026 9:42 PM
After a dominant 2025 campaign, the veteran southpaw's sharp decline and struggles against lefties are raising alarms as declining metrics and predictable sequencing plague his performance in Chicago.
It was a no-brainer for the Chicago Cubs to bring back reliever Caleb Thielbar for this season.
He was really one of the Cubs’ most consistent bullpen arms in 2025. The southpaw finished with a 2.64 ERA and 56 strikeouts across 58 innings pitched, and his strong metrics suggested that he could repeat his successful season again this year.
Thielbar ranked in the top 25% of the league in expected ERA (2.49), expected batting average against (.200), average exit velocity (87.9 mph), chase rate (32.3%), walk rate (5.9%), barrel rate (6.6%), and hard-hit rate (31.8%).
Unfortunately, the veteran has not been as consistent on the mound in 2026. His age appears to finally be catching up to him, as his overall metrics are down across the board through the first two months.
Related stories
Thielbar is allowing more walks (11.3% walk rate), giving up more barrels (10.3% barrel rate), and allowing much harder contact (37.5% hard-hit rate). He’s even allowing more contact in the air on the hitter’s pullside at 27.5% (up 9% from 2025).
There’s no denying the 39-year-old hasn’t been as sharp on the mound this season. He has especially not been as dominant against left-handed batters.
Lefties slashed .161/.211/.276 with 27 strikeouts against Thielbar in 2025. This year, lefties are batting .263 with only four strikeouts across 22 plate appearances. For a pitcher who has thrived on getting lefties out in his career, it’s concerning that he hasn’t.
Cubs fans saw that exactly in Saturday’s win over the San Francisco Giants.
Ben Brown was cruising in Saturday’s outing. He allowed just one hit in his first five innings and got the first batter to line out in the top of the sixth inning. Then, manager Craig Counsell replaced Brown with Thielbar to face the lefty-swinging Rafael Devers.
Thielbar got ahead in the count against Devers by throwing three straight fastball highs. The count stood at 1-2 before the Cubs left-hander threw another fastball high that the Giants slugger got ahold of for a home run.
It’s interesting that Thielbar threw four straight high fastballs in this at-bat against Devers. He didn’t even challenge him with an off-speed pitch or even throw a fastball higher up in the zone. He gave him the same pitch in the same location as the first pitch in the plate appearance.
If there’s any optimism with Thielbar moving forward, it’s that his expected ERA (3.63) is 67 points lower than his actual ERA (4.20). His expected batting average against (.205) also ranks in the top half of the league.
Still, the Cubs southpaw has been a major disappointment this season.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


