Giolito Is an Affordable Rotation Gamble for Diamondbacks
Nov 9, 2026 5:00 PM

The Arizona Diamondbacks could find low-risk stability in Lucas Giolito, a high-upside starter seeking an opportunity to bounce back following an injury-plagued season.

The Arizona Diamondbacks might lose Michael Soroka and Zac Gallen in free agency, leaving substantial vacancies in their starting rotation.

Gallen struggled throughout the season and also experienced inflammation in his right elbow. His performance and health problems create additional uncertainty for Arizona as it develops its pitching plans for 2027.

Gallen’s possible departure could leave Corbin Burnes, Eduardo Rodríguez, Ryne Nelson, Merrill Kelly and Brandon Pfaadt as the remaining rotation options.

Creating sufficient depth will be every bit as important as deciding which pitchers should occupy the leading spots on the staff. Arizona cannot reasonably depend on the same five starters remaining healthy, available and productive throughout an entire season.

Related stories

With that requirement in mind, Lucas Giolito could provide the Diamondbacks with a potential solution.

How Giolito fits with Diamondbacks

Recent seasons have produced several examples of pitchers encountering problems after signing late in free agency. Giolito experienced that situation in 2026.

The right-hander made only seven appearances (five starts) for the San Diego Padres and finished with a 5.16 ERA and 1.85 WHIP in 29.2 innings.

Giolito also missed the postseason because of inflammation in his right elbow, placing another concern beside his limited workload and disappointing results.

His 2025 performance offered a considerably different picture. Giolito recorded a 3.41 ERA and 1.29 WHIP in 145 innings over 26 starts for the Boston Red Sox.

That season demonstrated that the talent remains present. Giolito should require almost no significant financial investment this winter, yet he possesses the ability to become at least a middle-of-the-rotation starter.

Arizona would need to examine his elbow closely before making a commitment. His limited 2026 season means the Diamondbacks could not reasonably sign him and assume their rotation was complete.

However, that uncertainty is also what could make him available at a manageable price. Giolito needs an opportunity to prove that his latest season reflected poor timing and physical trouble rather than a permanent decline.

A short-term agreement would allow him to compete for a starting position without forcing Arizona to guarantee him one.

The Diamondbacks could gradually evaluate his workload during Spring Training and determine whether he is prepared to handle regular turns.

Giolito’s upside

Giolito would give the rotation another established option behind Burnes, Rodríguez, Nelson, Kelly and Pfaadt. His presence would also reduce the pressure on Arizona to promote a younger pitcher before that player is prepared.

The difference between his 2025 and 2026 seasons makes him a risk, but it also creates the possibility of obtaining meaningful production without a substantial contract.

Arizona needs affordable additions because replacing Soroka and Gallen with expensive starters may not be realistic. Giolito fits that approach as a pitcher whose recent struggles should lower his price without completely eliminating his potential.

With improved health and a complete preparation period, Giolito could rebuild his value while giving the Diamondbacks the dependable innings their rotation will need.

1
Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy