The race to sign star outfielder Kyle Tucker is beginning to narrow, with the picture around his free agency becoming clearer as January progresses. Industry chatter over the past week has consistently pointed to three teams standing at the forefront of the bidding: the Toronto Blue Jays, Los Angeles Dodgers, and New York Mets.

All three organizations have now formally engaged Tucker, either through in-person meetings or virtual discussions, signaling that the sweepstakes are entering a more serious phase.

MLB Network Radio’s Jim Duquette reported that Tucker has already met with each of the three clubs, reinforcing earlier indications that they are the most motivated suitors.

Those sentiments have since been echoed by several prominent insiders across the league, further cementing Toronto, Los Angeles, and New York as the primary players in what could become one of the offseason’s defining signings.

Toronto continues to loom large in Tucker speculation. The Blue Jays have been widely viewed as the team most willing to commit to a lengthy, franchise-altering contract. Their aggressiveness this winter supports that perception.

Coming off a crushing World Series loss to the Dodgers, Toronto has moved quickly to fortify its roster, committing significant money to starters Dylan Cease and Cody Ponce while also adding reliever Tyler Rogers and infielder Kazuma Okamoto.

Those moves suggest a front office determined to capitalize on its championship window, and Tucker would fit neatly into that vision as a middle-of-the-order cornerstone.

The Dodgers and Mets, meanwhile, appear to be approaching the pursuit from a different angle. Both clubs are believed to prefer a deal with a higher annual value but fewer long-term years attached. For Los Angeles, that strategy aligns with a roster already stacked with star power.

The Dodgers have supplemented their championship core by signing closer Edwin Díaz and retaining veteran Miguel Rojas, positioning themselves for another deep October run. Adding Tucker would further lengthen a lineup built to overwhelm opponents.

New York’s situation is more complicated. While the Mets have brought in several notable names this offseason, their winter has been marked just as much by departures as additions. Losing multiple foundational players has created uncertainty, making Tucker not just a luxury, but potentially a stabilizing force for a reshaped roster.

Even if the Mets have less positional need in the outfield than Toronto or Los Angeles, the stakes may be higher for them to land a marquee talent.

Another variable hovering over the Tucker market is Cody Bellinger. Like Tucker, Bellinger remains unsigned and has drawn interest from the same trio of teams. How his situation resolves could influence contract structures, timing, and leverage across the market.

The Yankees, once thought to be strong contenders for Bellinger, are now reportedly preparing for the possibility that he signs elsewhere, which could open additional ripple effects among remaining free agents.

Tucker, who spent the 2025 season with the Cubs following a trade from Houston, appears unlikely to return to Chicago. The Cubs’ recent acquisition of Alex Bregman on a long-term deal has further reduced the chances of a reunion, shifting Tucker’s focus squarely toward new opportunities.

As negotiations continue, the contrast in philosophies between the Blue Jays’ willingness to go long and the Dodgers’ and Mets’ preference for flexibility could ultimately decide where Tucker lands. For now, the competition remains fierce, and the outcome may reshape the balance of power in the National and American Leagues alike.

Don't miss out on our ROUNDTABLE community and the latest news!

It's completely free to join. Share your thoughts, engage with our Roundtable writers, and chat with fellow members.

Download the free Roundtable APP, and stay even more connected!