The San Francisco Giants entered 2026 without overwhelming expectations, but the season has still fallen short of what the organization hoped to achieve.

At 29-43, San Francisco sits 16 games behind the Los Angeles Dodgers in the National League West, and the outlook in the Wild Card race has become increasingly difficult.

Because of that position in the standings, attention is beginning to shift toward the trade deadline.

While the exact extent of the Giants’ approach remains unclear, the expectation around the league is that San Francisco will operate as a seller and move at least some pieces before the deadline.

One player drawing increasing attention is Casey Schmitt.

Mark Feinsand from MLB.com recently highlighted several players whose trade value has been rising, and Schmitt appeared on that list. At the same time, Feinsand suggested San Francisco may ultimately hesitate to move him.

Feinsand’s assessment centered on Schmitt’s importance to the current roster, noting that he has been one of the Giants’ strongest performers this season. He also pointed out that Schmitt’s defensive versatility and offensive breakout would likely create significant interest across the league if the organization decided to make him available.

“Schmitt has been the Giants’ best player in 2026, so trading the 27-year-old might not be in the cards for San Francisco. But Schmitt would be an attractive trade candidate for many teams given his versatility in the field, and given his breakout offensive season, the Giants could look to capitalize on his value if they decide to become big sellers,” Feinsand wrote. 

That possibility creates an interesting decision for San Francisco.

The Giants already have players on expiring contracts who appear more likely to be moved, including left-hander Robbie Ray and three-time batting champion Luis Arraez.

However, if the front office decides to pursue a more aggressive selloff, Schmitt’s name could become part of those discussions.

The 27-year-old infielder remains under club control for three seasons after 2026 and is not scheduled to reach free agency until 2030.

That level of control could significantly increase his market value and potentially allow San Francisco to acquire a meaningful package of prospects.

Given the direction of the season, additional long-term talent would provide value.

Since the franchise’s World Series years, the Giants have largely remained competitive without fully committing to a complete rebuild.

Trading Schmitt would represent a much more definitive shift in direction.

Schmitt is hitting .276 with 15 home runs, 38 RBIs and an .817 OPS in 64 games this season, production that strengthens his appeal for contending clubs searching for lineup help and positional flexibility.

If San Francisco makes him available, interest around the league would likely be substantial.

The larger question is philosophical.

Do the Giants continue trying to bridge the gap, or do they commit to building for the future?

With the Dodgers, San Diego Padres, and Arizona Diamondbacks continuing to set the pace in the division, San Francisco still appears to have significant ground to make up.

How the organization handles the trade deadline may reveal which path it ultimately chooses.

Don’t miss out on our ROUNDTABLE community and the latest news!

It’s completely free to join. Share your thoughts, engage with our Roundtable writers, and chat with fellow members.

Download the free Roundtable APP, and stay even more connected!