By signing Tyler Mahle to a one-year contract, the Giants appear increasingly committed to a depth-driven rotation strategy — even as questions linger about the group’s overall ceiling.
The San Francisco Giants continued their cautious approach to reshaping the starting rotation by finalizing a one-year, $10 million agreement with right-hander Tyler Mahle. The signing marks the club’s second short-term addition to the pitching staff this offseason, following the two-year, $22 million deal given to Adrian Houser in December.
Together, the moves signal a clear organizational preference: reinforce the rotation with reliable, lower-risk arms rather than pursuing a headline-grabbing ace.
That strategy stands in contrast to the expectations of some fans, particularly after president of baseball operations Buster Posey identified pitching as the franchise’s top offseason priority.
However, the front office has consistently indicated a reluctance to take on long-term or high-cost commitments, and the Mahle and Houser signings fit squarely within that framework.
General manager Zack Minasian suggested that the Giants may already be nearing the end of their rotation-building efforts. Speaking with reporters, Minasian emphasized the organization’s improved pitching depth and expressed confidence in the current group heading into spring training.
Mahle and Houser are expected to join Landen Roupp in the back half of the rotation, pitching behind established starters Logan Webb and Robbie Ray. While that quintet lacks a second true frontline arm behind Webb, the Giants believe their depth gives them protection against injuries and underperformance.
That depth comes in the form of a sizable group of young pitchers on the 40-man roster, including Hayden Birdsong, Keaton Winn, Carson Whisenhunt, Trevor McDonald, Carson Seymour and Blade Tidwell.
Each has some remaining minor-league options and the flexibility to contribute either as a spot starter or in a multi-inning bullpen role, providing the club with versatility throughout the season.
Still, the rotation’s upside remains a point of debate. Webb continues to anchor the staff as one of the National League’s most dependable aces, but Ray’s production declined noticeably after a strong start last season.
While he finished with solid overall numbers, his effectiveness waned in the second half as his strikeout rate dropped and run prevention became more inconsistent.
Houser and Mahle also carry question marks. Houser rebounded from a slow start last season with a strong run in Chicago before struggling again after a midseason move.
Mahle, meanwhile, delivered excellent results in limited action with Texas, but his reduced strikeout rate and recent injury history — including Tommy John surgery and recurring shoulder issues — make durability a concern.
Financial considerations appear to be shaping the Giants’ approach as well. With projected payroll nearing $185 million and a sizable deferred payment owed to Blake Snell, the club still has notable needs elsewhere on the roster. Right field remains unsettled, the bullpen lacks a proven late-inning presence, and second base could still be upgraded.
Given those factors, the Giants may prioritize addressing position-player needs rather than reallocating resources toward a higher-end starter.
Unless a trade opportunity aligns with their financial and prospect constraints, San Francisco seems prepared to bet on internal growth — hoping Roupp or one of the younger arms can emerge and elevate the rotation beyond its current expectations.
Join the Community
Don't miss out on our ROUNDTABLE community and the latest news!
It's completely free to join. Share your thoughts, engage with our Roundtable writers, and chat with fellow members.
Download the free Roundtable APP, and stay even more connected!