Nov 8, 2026 1:55 AM
Cleveland Guardians' Chase DeLauter wasn't a Rookie of the Year finalist, but should he have been?
Even before the 2026 season started, the Cleveland Guardians knew they had a rookie candidate on their Opening Day roster.
As it turns out, the Guardians did have a contender and one of the three finalists for the award, but maybe not who they initially thought.
When the top three players for the award were announced last week, it ended up being Cleveland’s own Parker Messick, Boston Red Sox’s Peyton Tolle, and Detroit Tigers’ Kevin McGonigle.
One player who wasn’t in the top three in voting but has an argument for being there is Chase DeLauter.
Related stories
Comparing DeLauter’s number to Messick and Tolle is pretty difficult, considering he essentially plays a different sport from them.
Pitching comes at such a premium, and when a rookie pitcher makes a strong impact like Messick and Tolle did, they’re going to get recognition for it, deservedly so.
That said, it is easy to compare DeLauter’s numbers to McGonigle’s, and they’re much closer than one may think.
May 17, 2026; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; Cleveland Guardians right fielder Chase DeLauter (24) celebrates on base as Cleveland Guardians first baseman Kyle Manzardo (not pictured) hits a more run during the third inning against the Cincinnati Reds at Progressive Field. Mandatory Credit: Ken Blaze-Imagn ImagesThe Guardians rookie finished with a .287/.363/.457 while Detroit’s rookie had a .278/.376/.430. That means DeLauter’s .820 OPS was slightly higher than McGonigle’s .806. Yes, McGonigle recorded two more home runs (18) than DeLauter (16), but the Cleveland outfielder had two more doubles than the Tigers infielder.
However, when you tally everything, DeLauter had a better overall OPS+ (131) than McGonigle (126).
The biggest difference, and the area where McGonigle has DeLauter clearly beat, is in WAR. The Tigers’ rookie finished with a 7.1, while DeLauter had just a 3.5. That likely came down to two things: games played and defensive position.
Both players were on their team’s Opening Day rosters, but McGonigle ended up playing 26 more games than DeLauter. But the Guardians rookie ended up on the injured list at one point in June and was day-to-day several times throughout the season. McGonigle finished his rookie year relatively healthy.
The Detroit rookie being on the field more certainly helped him finish with a better WAR.
On top of that, McGonigle was rewarded in that stat category for playing a more premium defensive position at third base. DeLauter spent his entire first year in right field, but also spent a lot of time as the team’s designated hitter.
The stats are close; there’s no question.
Whether voters got the finalists right will always be subjective. An argument can be made that DeLauter should be a finalist, but it’s also understandable to see why he wasn’t in the top three.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


