Nov 16, 2026 4:15 PM
Updated Nov 16, 2026 4:22 PM
The Mariners aren't bringing Crawford back in 2027, but that doesn't mean his legacy isn't set.
Brady Farkas and Buster Olney speak on the 'Refuse to Lose Territory' podcast. Subscribe on YouTube!More Videos
Last week, the Seattle Mariners reportedly told longtime infielder J.P. Crawford that he won't be back in 2027, despite Crawford saying at the end of 2026 that he wanted to be.
I said that I was surprised that the Mariners were closing the door on a Crawford reunion so quickly, but Buster Olney of ESPN told us that he wasn't surprised, and he outlined why.
In speaking with Olney, I made a comment about Crawford one day potentially landing in the Mariners Hall of Fame. Generally, that comment was panned on social media by people who don't think Crawford is a Hall of Famer, so let's dig a little deeper.
Crawford doesn't feel like a Hall of Famer
Look, I said the words, and I believe Crawford might get in to the Hall of Fame, but if you're not buying it, I understand it. Crawford doesn't feel like a Hall of Famer. He never posted gaudy numbers. He never even made an All-Star team. His contributions to the organization were more about steady and reliable play, as well as loyalty.
Related stories
Alex Rodriguez feels like a Hall of Famer more. Kyle Seager feels like a Hall of Famer more. And, heck, there's even a case to be made for Mitch Haniger too. And maybe Harold Reynolds.
But that doesn't change the fact that I think Crawford might get in.
The Crawford Hall of Fame case
1) Crawford is ranked No. 9 on the franchise's all-time WAR list for position players. He's ahead of Alvin Davis and Dan Wilson, who are both in the team's Hall of Fame.
2) He's 10th in offensive WAR.
3) And for all the questions about his regressing defense? Crawford is still 10th in defensive WAR also. He did win a Gold Glove Award in 2020.
4) He's 10th in franchise history in games played, so there's a longevity factor here. He's also played the most games in team history at shortstop, a position of major cache. He has the 10th-most at-bats in team history too. He's 10th in runs scored. He's seventh in walks drawn.
5) And again, whether you like it or not, there's a loyalty factor at play. Crawford spent eight years in Seattle. For a franchise that has been marred by its inability to retain players, Crawford stayed. He signed a contract extension. That loyalty matters in the same way it matters for Seager and Felix Hernandez.
6) And there's the drought factor: When the Mariners re-imagined the roster after the 2018 season, Crawford was the first player that the organization targeted. In many ways, he was the face of the team's rebuild and the face of hope for the future. And he delivered on that hope when he helped the Mariners break the drought and get to the playoffs in 2022.
There's absolutely a special place in team history for guys who were part of that group. And he might one day be rewarded for it.
1
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


