Nov 20, 2026 2:57 PM
Jon Morosi of MLB Network made the suggestion on Thursday and sent Mariners social media into a frenzy.
Brady Farkas speaks on the most recent 'Refuse to Lose Territory' podcast. Subscribe on YouTube!More Videos
On Thursday, Jon Morosi of MLB Network sent Seattle Mariners social media into a frenzy when he suggested that the M's could trade Brendan Donovan in the wake of acquiring Maikel Garcia.
Now, I will contend that Morosi was merely speculating and conversing, and not really reporting, but regardless, the idea of trading Donovan picked up steam throughout the night.
So, let's talk through this together and lay out some facts.
The conclusion that some are making
Morosi isn't the only one suggesting the Mariners could trade Donovan. I've seen Yankees and Phillies sites suggesting that their teams call the Mariners about a Donovan trade now too.
Related stories
The thought process here? Donovan started at third base last season, so since Garcia will be starting at third base next season, there's no place for Donovan in Seattle anymore.
What Jerry Dipoto has said about Donovan's role
We spoke with Dipoto following the Mariners' acquisition of Garcia on Wednesday, and I specifically asked the question about what the move means for Donovan's future.
Dipoto certainly didn't speak like a guy who is planning on trading the versatile Donovan. He mentioned that the trade that would likely force Donovan to more of an outfield role, but that he could also utilize his versatility to play other places as needed.
And that makes sense: If Cole Young needs a breather at second base, Donovan can step in. If Colt Emerson needs a breather at shortstop, then Garcia can slide to shortstop and Donovan can play third.
His versatility is a big piece of importance for this team.
Other questions the Mariners need to answer
As of right now, the Mariners figure to have Donovan in left field, Julio Rodriguez in center and Dominic Canzone in right field. This leaves the DH spot to one of Michael Arroyo or Lazaro Montes.
If the Mariners acquire another slugger like Seiya Suzuki, then both of the young players are squeezed out.
And while that would be disappointing, remember this: Donovan is a free agent after 2027. The team could simply stash at least one of those players in the minor leagues and wait for the 2028 campaign. They don't have to trade Donovan in order to open up room for them.
Why trading Donovan makes little sense
1) He's got versatility this team needs
2) He's only going to be 30 years old next season
3) They'd be selling awfully low, considering he played in only 39 games last season
4) They gave up a lot to get him, including prospect Tai Peete, who just won Offensive Player of the Year in the Arizona Fall League
5) He's not making very much money, with just over $6 million likely headed his way in arbitration
6) We're headed for a lockout and it's a possibility that we miss games in 2027. Who is trading anything of value for a player with only one year left of team control when you have no idea how much you'll actually get from him?
7) Donovan is a good player. The Mariners targeted him for a reason.
The only way that trading Donovan makes sense
If the Mariners are acquiring another position of need, for a player that also only has one year left of team control, then this could make more sense.
Steven Kwan of the Cleveland Guardians, a traditional left fielder, makes sense. Jhoan Duran of the Philadelphia Phillies could make sense for the bullpen as well.
But these 1-for-1 expiring deals are about the only way this idea actually makes any sense, at least to me.
4
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


