Sep 1, 2026 5:01 PM
Updated Sep 1, 2026 5:34 PM

There's a lot of fans who want the Mariners to bottom out this season to enact change, but how much change is on the table?

Brady Farkas talks on the 'Refuse to Lose Territory' podcast. Subscribe on YouTube! More Videos

The Seattle Mariners fell to 64-74 on Monday night with a devastating loss against the Boston Red Sox, and their playoff hopes tumbled all the way to 12 percent with it.

Seattle is now six games back in the American League West with 24 games to play, but again, even thinking about the playoffs right now feels like a pointless exercise.

What is a good exercise, at least mentally, is what much of the collective fanbase is doing online.

Would you rather see the team get hot at the end, have a poor record and make the playoffs, which would probably yield the organization doing the status quo heading into 2027?

Related stories

Or, would you rather the team get hot at the end, but fall just short, also possibly leading to the status quo in 2027?

Or, would you rather the team bottom out, be horrible down the stretch, and hope that the bottoming out leads to real changes in the offseason?

There's a lot of people opting for the latter, and while I can understand the sentiment, I have real fear with it as well. 

Here's why:

Bottoming-out would lead to a managerial change

Most of you are clamoring for Dan Wilson to be removed from his post at this point, and while I've defended him most of the year for a variety of reasons, I don't ultimately care who the manager is as long as they do a good job and the clubhouse supports them.

So, a managerial change would happen, and I think everyone would ultimately be OK with that.

Once there's a managerial change, there's a high probability of major staff change as well. That means you're talking about new hitting coaches, and maybe even a new pitching coach, as well as a new bench coach and on down the list.

I don't think most fans care as much about the entirety of the staff, but there are certainly valuable people that would be let go. More people to hire means more people to get right and a greater chance of getting it wrong. 

It's not the biggest worry of mine, but it's at least noteworthy that bringing in an entire new staff is hard.

It could lead to front office turnover

Again, most of you want Jerry Dipoto and Justin Hollander removed from their posts as well. I understand the sentiment there too, as they've built the rosters which have fallen short in various ways over the last decade.

I have less desire to see them removed, but again, I understand the position of fans who do. 

I would be, at least somewhat worried about the scouting and player development people they've hired and cultivated also being gone. Drafting and developing is something the organization has done well, and I'd hate to upset the apple cart on that front.

Before a game against the Colorado Rockies at T-Mobile Park, Seattle Mariners majority owner John Stanton, left, president of business operations Kevin Martinez, catcher Cal Raleigh (29), and president of baseball operations Jerry Dipoto pose for a photo with a framed poster commemorating the 57th home run of the season by Raleigh, breaking a team record. Joe Nicholson-Imagn ImagesBefore a game against the Colorado Rockies at T-Mobile Park, Seattle Mariners majority owner John Stanton, left, president of business operations Kevin Martinez, catcher Cal Raleigh (29), and president of baseball operations Jerry Dipoto pose for a photo with a framed poster commemorating the 57th home run of the season by Raleigh, breaking a team record. Joe Nicholson-Imagn Images

The real fear

To be honest, my real fear is this. If the team fires Dipoto and Hollander, and someone new comes in, we have absolutely no idea what they will do.

Will they continue to build the roster around Cal Raleigh, Julio Rodriguez, Josh Naylor and the pitching staff? We just don't know. And that terrifies me.

I'm 36 years old. I've seen six playoff berths. Some of you have seen less playoff berths. I don't have the energy or the patience for another rebuild.

What stops a new front office from trading Logan Gilbert with a year left on his contract? What stops a new front office from trading George Kirby with two years left? What stops them from moving Andres Munoz, who still has an affordable deal? And how about Gabe Speier? These are all moves that could happen, and none of them particularly excite me.

While I don't think they would do it because of the PR hit they would take, what stops someone from at least listening on Raleigh, who is signed to an affordable deal? 

When Dipoto was hired in 2015, to his credit, he tried to win with the existing core of Robinson Cano, Felix Hernandez, Kyle Seager and Nelson Cruz. He didn't immediately come in and "blow it up," but it's always my fear that someone new will come in and do just that.

And that's something I have absolutely no desire to see. I understand you might need to make a move here or there in order to shake things up, or you may want to shed a contract here in order to make a move there. I get that. That's baseball.

But I'd rather see whatever staff is in place try to maximize/fix current players than go out and trade them for more prospects. Someone from the outside may come in and think the M's need a full overhaul, and I don't want that.

Moral of the story

You want change. You want turnover. I get it, but be careful what you wish for, because you never know how far change can go.

Of note

The most recent edition of the 'Refuse to Lose Territory' podcast is out. You can listen here, or you can watch in the YouTube player below.

2
Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy