The Miami Marlins could be ready to spin the roulette wheel this offseason, but they aren't about to push all their chips into the middle of the table without getting something substantial in return.

According to reporting from the Miami Herald's Barry Jackson, the Marlins are willing to listen to offers for All-Star shortstop Otto Lopez and second baseman Xavier Edwards. Neither player is officially on the trading block, but Miami's front office apparently isn't displaying a completely emotionless poker face, either.

As Jackson reported, neither Lopez nor Edwards is considered absolutely untouchable. However, Miami would need to receive "a lot" in return before seriously considering a deal. That distinction is important for a franchise that has built its blueprint around acquiring young talent, not trading it away.

Lopez is coming off a spectacular 2026 season. He batted .305 with 11 home runs, 71 runs batted in, and 34 stolen bases, collecting 191 hits to lead the majors. His first All-Star selection underscored his emergence as one of the National League's most productive shortstops.

Edwards also delivered a strong campaign, hitting .280, with six homers, 51 RBI, and 21 steals. The switch-hitter has established himself as an effective table-setter, giving Miami another player capable of putting pressure on opposing defenses.

Both infielders are under team control through the 2029 season, giving the Marlins considerable leverage in negotiations. Lopez is projected to earn approximately $5.4 million through arbitration in 2027, while Edwards' projected salary is around $3.5 million.

Fortunately, the Marlins have potential internal replacements. Javier Sanoja enjoyed an encouraging season at third base and can play second, while Jared Serna could compete for a larger role.

Prospect Aiva Arquette is another potential long-term option as he advances through the minor leagues. Miami also has pressing needs elsewhere. The Marlins ranked 23rd in home runs in 2026, highlighting their need for additional power.

Their pitching staff could also benefit from reinforcements, making a trade of either infielder potentially useful if it brings back impact arms or high-upside prospects.

The Marlins don't have to bet the house. They can simply keep their options open, study the offers, and wait for another team to raise the stakes. But if a rival presents an irresistible package, Miami could take a chance on a different future.

Otherwise, the smartest move might be to leave its two middle infielders where they are.In this offseason's high-stakes game, the Marlins appear willing to gamble. They're just not willing to play for pennies.

Trading either infielder could address critical roster needs by landing impact pitchers or top-tier prospects, especially given Miami's desire for additional power on offense. Ultimately, Miami must decide whether Lopez and Edwards are cornerstones of its next competitive team or valuable cards that could help it assemble an even stronger hand.

Rather than rushing into a move, Peter Bendix will evaluate incoming offers and let the market dictate the price. If a competitor delivers an overwhelming proposal, Miami may pivot. In essence, the Fish will stand pat with its middle-infield duo... unless the pot gets too sweet to fold.