Oct 1, 2026 9:00 PM

Miami is in a different position than many of baseball's biggest franchises and needs the owners to 'win' this one

It will be an offseason of uncertainty as the Miami Marlins and the rest of Major League Baseball's ownership faction and the Players Association are set to lock horns in a labor dispute, which could be feast or famine for a fresh-faced team like the Fish.

The current MLB Collective Bargaining Agreement expires on December 1, 2026. If there is an impasse and a lockout occurs, only players not on the organization's 40-man roster can take part in team activities. That was a major reason why some teams were apprehensive about activating and adding some of the future stars this Fall; a long-term labor stoppage would not allow them access to team facilities to practice, work out, and study strategy. But if they remain off the 40-man list, they can take full advantage of any time off to turn the page in their careers.

At the same time, no one gets realistically better without reps. And the flip side of quietly developing up-and-coming talent during the time off is the fact that all your veteran players get a year older. Yes, they get some time to heal the common wear and tear that a 162-game schedule takes out of them. But a year is a year. So, players aren't just losing time and games; they are losing miles off their own personal odometer, as well. For a clear example in Miami? Look at Sandy Alcantara. At 31 years old, he likely doesn't want to lose any more prime seasons that he's healthy for.

President of baseball operations Peter Bendix says the team is going to go to work as if the matter will be settled in time to play ball on time in 2027. That remains to be seen, but the executive is trying to at least elicit that same of thought process throughout the organization.

Related stories

"Nobody has any idea what's going to happen in the lockout. Those are discussions that are taking place elsewhere," Bendix said on September 29. "My job is to focus on the Marlins and to prepare to play 162 games."

"Five years ago, we dealt with something similar where there was this pending date where things were gonna be cut off, and we kind of know what to expect with that, and we're spending a lot of time preparing, so we'll hit the ground running."

What's the Best Strategy for the Marlins?

Despite Bendix saying the team is operating as if it's going to business as usual, most members of the MLB media, outside observers, and even some team executives have voiced concerns that the regular season may not open until June or July... or possibly there could be no season at all. That's where we stand in general, and why Marlins fans have to be wondering what may become of their rising roster. 

The Fish (80-82 this season) are a team on the brink of greatness. At least if the all the prospects down in the waters to end up being as good as advertised. So, a salary cap would give the organization a chance to add some short-term, mid-level free agents that could fortify the Fish for next season's playoff run.

A salary floor wouldn't effect the team too much right now, but it might in the long run. For the immediate future, the Marlins and the fans in South Florida should be rooting for the owners in this one. If the accordion between the top and the bottom spenders gets pushed in a little bit further? Then there should be sweet music playing in Miami for a long time.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy