Miami has a clear need at the corners, and Mayo fits the 3B/1B mold. But Baltimore’s early injuries may have turned him from trade chip into necessity.
The Miami Marlins are still in that awkward phase where "building for tomorrow" can’t be an excuse to ignore obvious upgrades today, especially at the corners.
If the front office is serious about stabilizing the Marlins' infield without committing long-term money, there’s a name that keeps popping up on the edges of the rumor mill: Baltimore Orioles corner bat Coby Mayo.
On paper, it’s the kind of target that makes too much sense for Miami.
Mayo is only 24, he has real pop, and Baltimore has spent the entire offseason looking like a team trying to solve a numbers problem at first base and DH. Once Pete Alonso joined the Orioles, the logjam got louder. Add in reports that Baltimore has at least explored the idea of moving Mayo and/or Ryan Mountcastle, and you can see why a club like Miami would circle Mayo as a buy-now-before-he-breaks-out candidate.
For the Marlins, the appeal is simple: Mayo can cover both third and first, which matters because Miami’s roster feels like it’s constantly one tweak away from a domino effect. Even if you don’t believe Mayo is a long-term third baseman, the versatility alone fits a team that needs options, not more single-position bets. A right-handed bat with upside who can rotate between corners is exactly the kind of controllable piece that can age well through a rebuild.
Here’s the catch -- the Orioles may have been open to moving Mayo when they were healthy and crowded. But spring injuries are already forcing their hand. With Jordan Westburg dealing with an elbow issue and expected to miss time, and Jackson Holliday out beyond Opening Day, Mayo suddenly looks less like surplus and more like a necessity. Baltimore didn’t just lose bodies; it lost infield certainty.
That’s why this could be one of those "great idea, wrong timing" trades for Miami. The Orioles can talk about shopping Mayo, but injuries have a way of turning trade chips into emergency starters overnight.
The Marlins should absolutely check in. Because teams don’t always admit when they’re desperate until it’s too late. But if Baltimore believes Mayo is now their best path to surviving April, Miami’s best play might be patience: keep the conversation alive, and pounce later if the Orioles get healthier or decide they still need pitching more than depth.
Join our ROUNDTABLE community! It's completely free to join. Share your thoughts, engage with our Roundtable writers, and chat with fellow members.
Download the free Roundtable APP, and stay even more connected!