Why Didn't the Marlins Protect These Prospects From Rule 5?
Nov 19, 2026 1:02 PM

Kemp Alderman, Karson Millbrandt, and Brayden Taylor are top MLB hopefuls that Marlin left exposed to be selected

While the Miami Marlins have certainly been a breath of fresh air in their approach to developing a strong youth movement, they curiously left three prominent prospects exposed in the 2026 MLB Rule 5 Draft.

The event is tentatively scheduled for December 9, but that date may be due to unrest surrounding Major League Baseball's Collective Bargaining Agreement. Plenty could be thrown off-kilter after the current deal expires at the beginning of next month.

For now, an examination of the layers available for selection by other teams. Rule 5 has seen some notable franchise moves in the past, and it's highly likely that three of Miami's budding big leaguers could be snatched away by another squad. 

A Rule 5 selection obligates the acquiring franchise to maintain the player on its active major league roster for the entire upcoming season, barring injured-list designations. This operational constraint deters claims on unrefined talent, but it does not completely mitigate the risk of another team acquiring a high-upside asset.

Related stories

Starting pitcher Karson Millbrandt, outfielder-first baseman Kemp Alderman, and 2B/3B Brayden Taylor were left off the team's 40-man roster and are therefore eligible to be taken in this year's R5. All three are considered among the Marlins' top ten overall prospects.

The most intriguing aspect of Miami's strategy is that these three players are not mere organizational depth. Each has demonstrated sufficient upside to merit an eventual big-league opportunity, with all three projected as future MLB contributors.

Three Names Stand Out

Start with Karson Millbrandt, a 22-year-old right-hander who was selected in the third round of the 2022 MLB Draft. The 6'2" hurler has certainly experienced his share of growing pains, particularly with his command, but the raw ingredients remain intriguing.

Millbrandt features a fastball sitting at 95 mph and topping out at 98, paired with a mid-80s sweeper, a gyro slider, and a curveball. He also mixes in a changeup, offering a diverse array of options to attack hitters.

Next on our list of head scratchers is Kemp Alderman, a second-round selection who played collegiately at Ole Miss in 2023. At some point, he was seen as a player who could eventually solve Miami's ongoing search for a reliable first baseman. Apparently, that's not the case now.

Alderman appeared in 105 games with the Jacksonville Jumbo Shrimp in 2026, hitting .254 with 19 home runs, 64 RBI, and 10 stolen bases. His .769 OPS wasn't spectacular, but the power is legitimate. His elite exit velocities and ability to contribute from multiple positions make him an intriguing offensive option.

Brayden Taylor represents a compelling profile amongst the group. Picked up from Tampa Bay as part of the exchange for Liam Hicks, the 24-year-old former first-round pick has established an ability to produce across multiple offensive metrics. In 2024, Taylor hit 20 home runs and stole 29 bases split between High-A and Double-A.

What's the Strategy in Miami?

While Millbrandt, Alderman, and Taylor may not reach that precise trajectory, their underlying metrics make the exposure strategic decision worthy of scrutiny.

The Marlins front office may have a clear risk-mitigation strategy behind leaving these players off the roster. However, should an opposing franchise claim one in December, Miami may find that preserving three 40-man roster spots yielded a net negative return on investment.

1
Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy