Nov 21, 2026 12:01 PM
The once-highly touted prospect has experienced a frustrating first five seasons as a New York Met, but his late-season performance in 2026 lends hope for a more impactful 2027.
If you are a New York Mets' fan and look up the word "frustrating" in a dictionary, you probably wouldn't be surprised if the definition, "causing annoyance or upset because of an inability to change or achieve something," was accompanied by a picture of Mets' infielder Brett Baty.
After being drafted 12th overall in the first round of the 2019 MLB Draft by the Mets, Baty was consistently highly ranked among the game's top minor-league prospects with his best standing being No. 13 and No. 17 by Baseball Prospectus in 2022 and 2023, and No. 21 by MLB Pipeline in 2023.
So, it was with great fanfare that Baty arrived in Queens in August 2022 for an 11-game cup of coffee followed by what appeared to be a permanent assignment as the Mets' everyday third baseman when he was recalled in mid-April 2023 and ended up playing 108 games with his season interrupted by a 26-day IL stint that cost him nearly the entire month of August.
In addition to the IL stint, it's no exaggeration to say that things did not go according to the Mets' long-term plan as Baty finished 2023 with a .212 average, .275 on-base percentage, .323 slugging percentage and .685 OPS with nine home runs, 34 RBIs and 10 errors in 100 games at third base, resulting in a -0.7 WAR.
Related stories
That was followed by a lost 2024 season in which he was banished to Triple-A Syracuse for 62 games, which limited him to 50 at the big-league level where he hit .229 with a .633 OPS thanks to three doubles, four HRs and only 16 walks to 42 strikeouts.
While Baty did appear in a total of 273 games over the 2025-26 seasons, the offensive results were essentially more of the same: .246 average, .716 OPS, 29 home runs, 105 RBIs and 77 walks to 233 strikeouts.
If there was one bright spot, it's that Baty morphed into one of the game's most versatile players with 23 or more games played at four positions in 2026: third (58), first (26), second (25), rightfield (23, with 30 overall on the grass), with 11 at designated hitter and three at shortstop thrown in for good measure. (Note to self: consider the newly four-position-eligible Baty for a late-round dart throw in next year's fantasy draft).
It wouldn't be untrue to suggest that some Mets' fans might be ready to cut bait with Baty at this point, but there is at least one voice who thinks he could be a candidate to fashion a breakout season akin to what the Milwaukee Brewers' previously unheralded first baseman Jake Bauers cobbled together in 2026.
That voice is MLB.com's Mike Petriello, who included Baty's name among four others who could potentially take Bauers' one-year turnaround route from afterthought to Silver Slugger winner and high-priced free-agent signing (Bauers inked a 4-year, $58-million FA deal with the Boston Red Sox on Tuesday).
Digging into the analytical numbers, Petriello lauds Baty's impressive bat speed, which remains among the top-10 percent of MLB batters, while his barrel rate is in the 77th percentile, meaning when he hits the ball he typically hits it hard, while he has also started to more consistently launch balls into the air.
The writer also notes that through June 30, 2026, Baty was hitting .210 with a .589 OPS, three HRs, 10 doubles, 27 RBIs and 77 strikeouts in 248 at-bats (31.1% strikeout rate), but he bumped his OPS to .722 in July and August before he finished the season with a flourish: a 1.061 OPS in September.
In 21 games played that month he hit .353 with five doubles, three home runs, eight walks and only 10 strikeouts in 51 at-bats (19.6% K rate), which provides hope that that three-week hot streak could be a harbinger of better things to come in 2027 for Baty.
"The bat speed remains excellent, and while the plate discipline is just OK, he added more loft to his swing in the second half, which helped get some more of that in the air; he did end up with the third-largest decline in ground-ball rate of any qualified hitter," Petriello summed up.
Though their fingers may remain crossed, words like that have to be music to the ears of Mets' fans who continue to dream on the long-awaited tongue-twister that would be a brilliant Brett Baty breakout.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


