Nov 17, 2026 5:13 PM
Coming off a sterling rookie campaign, New York Mets' pitcher Nolan McLean is seen by some to have what it takes to become a major award-winner next season.
As far as bright spots go, New York Mets' pitcher Nolan McLean's rookie season was as bright as the light from a thousand suns, at least when compared to most of the goings-on that epitomized New York's dysfunctional and ultimately disastrous 74-88 2026 season.
After McLean rolled up a 12-10 record with a 3.16 ERA, 128 ERA+ and 1.17 WHIP with 194 strikeouts and only 140 hits allowed over 179.2 innings pitched, the postseason recognition came rolling in:
• MLB All-Rookie Second Team
• 4th in NL Rookie of the Year voting
Related stories
• First rookie pitcher to win a Gold Glove Award
The writers at MLB.com also listed McLean among the top 12 2026 rookies, in both the NL and AL, that they expected to produce the most future value for their teams throughout the course of their careers.
But one specific MLB.com writer, Will Leitch, thinks McLean could go beyond all that and actually swim in the deepest end of the postseason-award pool as early as next season.
On Nov. 14, Leitch predicted that McLean could be one of the top five pitchers in the game to win his first Cy Young Award in 2027.
Leitch's article was prompted by the fact that all four of the winners of MLB's top individual awards in 2026 - Cy Young and MVP - were first-time honorees, with the Milwaukee Brewers' Jacob Misiorowski and New York Yankees' Cam Schlittler, who were also completing their first full MBL seasons in 2026, becoming unanimous Cy Young winners in the NL and AL, respectively.
With that in mind, he listed McLean as one of three NL pitchers that could become a first-time Cy Young winner next year, reasoning:
"If you’re looking for a young starter to make a Misiorowski- or Schlittler-like leap in 2027, perhaps it’s McLean? The 25-year-old doesn’t throw as hard as the Miz...[b]ut he was nearly as effective in the second half, putting up a 2.61 ERA over 12 starts after the All-Star break for a Mets team that was a lot better down the stretch than anyone noticed. It remains to be seen if the Mets land Tarik Skubal this offseason, but for now, McLean is the clear ace of this staff. Even if Skubal comes to Queens, McLean is going to be a player the Mets build around for years to come, and for good reason."
As far as competition for McLean as a first-time NL Cy Young winner in 2027, Leitch highlights two possibilities, one an established veteran and the other an up-and-coming star like McLean.
The Philadelphia Phillies' Cristopher Sanchez has back-to-back Cy Young finishes under his belt, placing behind Misiorowski this year and the Pittsburgh Pirates' Paul Skenes in 2025.
Sanchez's last two seasons have seen him compile identical 8.1 WARs, both of which led all MLB pitchers in 2025 and 26, while his 18 wins in 2026 were tops in the majors. Since 2025, he is 31-12 with a combined 2.70 ERA in 409 innings pitched.
The Cincinnati Reds' Chase Burns is a contemporary of McLean's who made his MLB debut in 2025. He actually has started two fewer games overall than McLean (39-37) since debuting, but in 29 starts in 2026, he went 15-3 for a team that was nearly as bad as the Mets (75-87 record) with a 2.86 ERA and 185 strikeouts in 154.1 innings pitched, which makes it obvious why Burns was included on Leitch's list of possible first-time Cy Young winners.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


