Signing Skubal Would Come With More Short Starts For Mets
Nov 22, 2026 3:01 AM

Tarik Skubal is projected as an ace who can't give length for the New York Mets, and that's a potential problem.

The New York Mets are the leaders in the clubhouse to land and overpay free agent starter Tarik Skubal. But there’s a lot to consider in this transaction, including what Tyler Kepner of The Athletic called the “less is more” possibility when it comes to the future that comes with giving a 30-year old pitcher a nine-year deal for nine figures, which is where most of the speculation lands right now. 

Kepner’s piece covers this issue in depth, and he raises all the right points. As he pointed out, Skubal’s career will offer a fascinating test case of pitching value in the less-is-more era of the craft. He has won two Cy Young Awards, but the left-handers arrives at his 30s with only 925 1/3 career innings pitched. Skubal’s managers have let him throw 100 pitches just 17 times in 160 career starts, or 10.6 percent. 

The counter argument is the way Skubal elevated his team, per Kepner. The Detroit Tigers were when Skubal started, and they were 131-131 when he did not. Skubal took the Tigers from .500 to October, and the Mets are hoping he can do the same for them. 

Skubal’s former manager in Detroit, A.J. Hinch, said that one inning at the end of an outing, which is 15 pitches at the 100-pitch mark, shouldn’t define the belief in the importance of that starter. He argued for the other tangibles and intangibls that Skubal brings to the mound and to the clubhouse, but Hinch should know better. 

Related stories

There’s no doubt about Skubal’s greatness, but for the Mets the problem is that they just went through this in 2026. The Mets thought they were going to get the same kinds of things when they traded for starter Freddy Peralta, whose alternate nickname was “Five-Inning Freddy.”

But Peralta turned into a puddle when he started to struggle, and the Mets couldn’t find a way out of it for him. The Tampa Bay Rays did, and it was the simple adjustment of having him abandon his windup and work from the stretch, then adjust his mechanics accordingly. 

It’s not hard to understand why the Mets want to have another go at this, though. Owner Steve Cohen loves to sign stars, and he sees this as his time of year. He’ll probably get his man in Skubal, but he may not love what he gets over the course of that hypothetical nine-year deal.

1
Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy