Nov 18, 2026 11:00 AM
As Pete Alonso thrives in Baltimore after one of his best years yet, New York faces the grim reality of a failed internal replacement and a vacant hole at first.
The New York Mets weren't represented on the list of 2026 Silver Slugger winners, but that doesn’t mean there weren't notable winners from a Mets perspective. Two former Mets players received the prestigious offensive award: center fielder Pete Crow-Armstrong and first baseman Pete Alonso.
PCA’s MVP season has drawn extensive attention as he exploded into a household name at just 24. A former Mets prospect who was dealt to the Chicago Cubs for Javier Baez in 2021, PCA’s blossoming into stardom has been a nightmare for Mets fans to watch. While PCA’s season deserves all the attention it has received, I want to focus on Alonso’s first season not in Mets pinstripes.
Alonso signed a five-year deal worth $155 million last offseason with the Baltimore Orioles – finally getting the long-term deal he deserved after a dry market in 2024 forced him to re-sign with the Mets and try his luck again the next offseason.
The 31-year-old not only lived up to that deal in his first season, but he made the rest of the league look like fools for not being more attracted to him on the free agent market. Alonso smashed 43 home runs and drove in 113 runs on his way to a 149 OPS+ and 5.0 bWAR. It was his best season since his rookie year in 2019, by the metrics.
Related stories
In case you don’t already know, if you want a reminder to give yourself night terrors, the Mets opted to sign Jorge Polanco to be the first baseman in 2026 instead of coming together on a deal for a franchise icon in Alonso. Polanco, who played a grand total of one game at first base in his career at the time of the signing, was even older than Alonso and signed a $20 million AAV deal over two years.
Already, Polanco’s Mets deal is a disaster. He missed most of the 2026 campaign due to injury and was unplayable when on the field. His .431 OPS across 37 games led to an abysmal -1.4 bWAR. The market value for players is around $10 million for every 1.0 WAR, meaning Polanco provided a net value of $-10.4 million in just 37 games of action. Compare that to Alonso’s net value of $50 million while being paid just $21 million by Baltimore.
The decision to let Alonso walk in free agency will go down as one of the biggest mistakes of President of Baseball Operations David Stearns’ tenure in New York. Keep in mind, Alonso wasn’t a bad mojo guy. He wasn’t making poor off-field decisions or bringing any unnecessary drama to the club. Alonso was a hero for the Mets over the seven years he was there.
So, while Alonso gets his deserved flowers and a second Silver Slugger Award in a different shade of orange, the Mets are currently scrambling to find a first baseman for 2027. Last offseason was poor for the Mets, and they finished last in the NL East as a result. Letting Alonso walk was just one of those moves, but let’s hope Stearns and the front office don’t make any mistake anywhere near as big as that one again.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


