Nov 6, 2026 5:17 PM
In a compilation of the most valuable players and teams in 2026, San Diego's Ty France and Mason Miller paced the Padres while the team finished 22nd overall in MLB.
The San Diego Padres' two most "valuable" players in 2026 - first baseman Ty France and closer Mason Miller - were their two lowest-paid regulars.
That's according to the "2026 Moneyball Rankings," which Bleacher Report's Joel Reuter released on Thursday.
This report attempts to determine which teams got the most bang for their buck in 2026 when balancing the amount of WAR an individual player created during the season against the salary they were paid.
Specifically, Reuter's formula assigns a value of $8 million for every one WAR, per the FanGraphs value metric, with the player's actual WAR multiplied by eight to determine the player's 2026 value in millions of dollars. The player's 2026 salary is then subtracted from the dollar value, which produces the player's 2026 net value. Obviously, positive net values are good and negative net values are not so good.
Related stories
For example, if a player produced 4.5 WAR and earned $15 million, the net value would be $21 million (4.5 x 8 - 15 = 21), which is a return any investor would be happy to receive.
As it pertains to the Padres, France was the team's biggest bargain in 2026 as he produced 4.5 WAR while playing for a relatively minuscule $2 million, which equates to a net value of $34 million.
Miller, arguably the game's best, if not the most dominant, closer was paid $4 million this season and produced 3.1 WAR for a $20.8 million net value.
Other high performers were starter Michael King ($17.4 million net value), outfielder Jackson Merrill ($16.2 million) and Fernando Tatis Jr., who overcome a terrible first two months to finish with 4.3 WAR and a net value of $14.4 million on his $20 million salary.
While that's a solid top five, the problem is that France and King are now free agents and no one is quite sure where they will ply their trade in 2027. A deeper look at the contributions of the other 52 players who played at least one game for the Padres in 2026 shows some warning signs, like a "check engine" light flashing on the dashboard.
Specifically, the team's two highest-paid players - shortstop Xander Bogaerts ($25 million this season) and third baseman Manny Machado ($21 million) - underperformed this year when compared to their past production with a combined 3.7 WAR that gave them a combined -$16.4 million in net value, while longtime mainstay Jake Cronenworth, who did battle injuries this year, had a net value of -$11.2 million due to his 0.1 WAR and $12-million salary.
Bounce-back seasons for those three are always possible in 2027, but when players age, significant rebounds are usually few and far between while the salaries in their long-term contracts either remain the same or increase, which places pressure on younger and cheaper players to maintain or improve their performance levels.
San Diego's trade deadline also turned into a disaster with starting pitching acquisitions Casey Mize and Robbie Ray, who are also free agents, combining for -$14.8 million in net value during their brief stays in the East Village.
Overall, the Padres rank 22nd in the Moneyball report as the entire roster produced $45.6 million, which put them in the neighborhood of the A's (21st, $50.9 million) and Los Angeles Angels ($23rd, $44.1 million), two franchises that didn't come close to sniffing the playoffs in 2026.
Still, it must be said the Padres had a successful 90-72 season, highlighted by the NL Wild Card Series sweep of the Chicago Cubs and their staunch showing against the eventual-champion Milwaukee Brewers in the NL Divisional Series.
But there are red flags, especially on the mound and in the increasing age of some core players, which makes this offseason a pivotal one for the team's front office and new ownership group if they wish to remain relevant in the National League moving forward.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


