Phillies Should Immediately Jump on This Incoming Firesale

The Philadelphia Phillies have been one of the best teams in baseball ever since firing Rob Thomson and replacing him with Don Mattingly.

At the time of the switch, the Phillies were 9-19. Since then, they have gone 33-16 to re-insert themselves into the National League playoff picture.

In fact, with the Atlanta Braves sliding a bit recently, a run at the NL East division title is not entirely out of the question.

That being said, Philadelphia still has some very obvious holes that need to be filled. Its lineup is very thin once you get past Kyle Schwarber, Bryce Harper and Brandon Marsh, its starting rotation lacks depth and it could really use some bullpen help.

Fortunately, the Phillies still have plenty of time between now and the MLB trade deadline to repair those issues, and there is one team that would represent an absolutely perfect partner for them in that regard: the San Francisco Giants.

The Giants are one of the worst teams in baseball and will almost certainly be selling before Aug. 3. They also have a bunch of players worth monitoring, and Philadelphia should be interested in just about all of them.

Luis Arraez is an obvious target who would comprise a major offensive upgrade over Bryson Stott at second base. Casey Schmitt and Jung Hoo Lee could represent sleeper outfield additions. Then, of course, you have Logan Webb and Robbie Ray, who would significantly bolster the Phillies' starting rotation.

Heck, even relief pitcher JT Brubaker could present Philadelphia with an intriguing trade acquisition.

Basically, Dave Dombrowski should be placing a call to San Francisco immediately to see if he can secure any of those names.

Arraez might be the most attractive, realistic option. He is a three-time batting champion who is slashing .320/.354/.444 this season, and he has struck out a grand total of 13 times. He is also only on a one-year, $12 million contract with the Giants, so the Phillies would have no financial obligation toward him beyond 2026.

The snag here is that Stott has been coming on in June after a miserable start to the season, so Philadelphia may choose to see it through with him for now.

Schmitt and Lee, on the other hand, would fill instant needs for the Phillies, who just lost Adolis Garcia for the season with a shoulder injury. And let's be honest: Garcia only had a .599 OPS, anyway.

The former is in the middle of a breakout campaign with San Francisco, hitting .296 with an .855 OPS. He is under club control through 2029, so the Giants don't have to be in any rush to move him, but they may want to capitalize on his value now.

Lee is a terrible defender, but he is slashing .327/.359/.456 with four home runs and 18 doubles this season. Like Arraez, he doesn't strike out much (26 strikeouts on the year), but the caveat is that he is making $23.5 million this season and is slated to collect another $23.5 million in 2027 before an opt out in his contract.

As for the pitchers, Webb has been a Cy Young contender for several years and owns a 3.35 ERA in 2026. The Phillies have two terrific starters in Cristopher Sanchez and Zack Wheeler, an inconsistent No. 3 in Jesus Luzardo and then not much else. He would be a tremendous addition, and even Ray would be in spite of his command issues.

Philadelphia should absolutely be sniffing around a potential (if not inevitable) Giants fire sale to see if it can come away with any of those players. All of them would significantly help Philly this season, and I find it hard to believe that Dombrowski is content with the roster as is.

Phillies Roundtable also offers a fan community and message board. We’d love to have you join us to talk all things Phillies. Click the “Join” button at the top of the page to join our community for free.