How Pirates Can Get Near First-Round Pick for Brandon Lowe, and Why It's Likely
Nov 19, 2026 3:56 PM

By rejecting a qualifying offer, Lowe could help the Pirates' future if he doesn't return.

In a decision that shouldn't have come as a surprise to anybody, Pittsburgh Pirates second baseman and free agent Brandon Lowe has decided to turn down the qualifying offer. 

I never thought the Pirates believed they were going to get Lowe on that qualifying offer, but there are some other reasons as to why Pittsburgh decided to offer him it. Remember now, just because Lowe decided to pass up on the qualifying offer doesn't mean that he can't return to the Pirates on a different deal. There seems to be an expectation in Major League Baseball that he could be looking at about a three-year, $75 million contract. 

As we've spoken about many times now, there's really no excuse for the Pirates not to give him that money, unless there's a belief that they can improve elsewhere and replace his bat. 

However, in that scenario, I'd want the Pirates to go out and bring back Lowe and also add another guy who can swing it with the best of them.

Related stories

But the Pirates made the decisions they did, and there's a lot of hope within the fan base that Lowe will return, no matter how. 

If he doesn't, however, there are some other benefits that could help the Pirates in the long term. The Pirates' MLB.com beat writer recently outlined how everything could unfold for Pittsburgh over the next couple of weeks, with him declining his qualifying offer potentially even ending up with the Pirates getting a first-round pick in the 2027 draft as a Competitive Balance Round A pick.

“If Lowe were to sign elsewhere for $50 million or more, Pittsburgh would now receive a 2027 Draft pick between the first round and Competitive Balance Round A. If he were to sign elsewhere for under $50 million, the compensation pick would come after Competitive Balance Round B. Lowe returning to the Pirates through free agency would not result in a compensatory Draft pick.

“Lowe became just the third Pirates player to receive a qualifying offer since its inception in 2012, joining Francisco Liriano and Russell Martin, both in 2014. With the Pirates, Lowe fortified his defense at second base, flipping a -10 fielding run value in 2025 with the Rays to a +12 in Pittsburgh. He became a Gold Glove finalist for the first time in his career,” Aiden Stepansky wrote.

Draft picks are always good, and as the Pirates have found out in the past, bringing in young players who can help the organization should be seen as a good thing. 

The Pirates have one of the best farm systems in baseball and can probably make a lot of trades because of that. However, we also have to recognize that draft picks aren't going to get the Pirates into the playoffs this season. 

For a fan base dying for success right now, I don't really know how the front office and Bob Nutting would be able to look at the fan base's face and say that they didn't let Lowe walk for anything other than money. 

Again, not to say that he isn't replaceable or the Pirates can't go out and get guys who can make an impact for them offensively, but if Lowe walks and that doesn't happen, there are going to be a lot of upset fans, and nobody's really going to care much about a draft pick.

2
Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy