Lost somewhat in the Tigers’ ongoing search for rotation reinforcements is the internal question of what Keider Montero can realistically be in 2026. While Detroit continues to explore external options to stabilize the middle of the rotation, Montero represents a different kind of evaluation—one centered on role definition, pitch quality, and where the little gains can translate into dependable innings at the major-league level.
Montero’s 2025 season was not a breakout, nor was it a collapse. It was something more complicated, and perhaps more revealing. The raw results, particularly in the second half, reinforce why Detroit remains active in the pitching market. At the same time, Statcast indicators suggest a pitcher whose underlying profile still offers a usable foundation if the role, usage, and expectations are aligned correctly.
The Surface Numbers vs. the Reality
From a percentile standpoint, Montero’s 2025 profile paints a familiar picture: below-average run prevention, modest strikeout ability, and limited margin for error. His overall pitching run value sat near the bottom quintile, while his expected ERA (xERA) and expected batting average (xBA) hovered in similarly low percentiles. This is not the statistical resume of a pitcher a contending team wants anchoring a rotation spot.
That context matters. Detroit’s interest in adding arms is not an indictment; it is a recognition of volatility. Montero’s whiff rate ranked in the low teens, his strikeout rate remained below league average, and his ability to miss bats simply did not support extended exposure to lineups multiple times through the order.
And yet, those same numbers also explain why the Tigers have not written him off.
A Pitch Mix That Still Plays—In Pieces
Montero is not a power pitcher, but he is not without weapons. His fastball velocity sits just below league average for right-handers, but its effectiveness has fluctuated year-to-year based on command rather than raw stuff. In 2025, the four-seamer graded closer to average in run value, an improvement from 2024, suggesting incremental gains in shape or usage.
Where the intrigue lies is in the secondary mix.
His slider remains his best bat-missing offering, posting a whiff rate north of 35 percent. The issue has never been quality—it has been consistency. When located, it generates chase and swing-and-miss. When elevated or backed up, it turns into a hittable spinner. That inconsistency became more pronounced as the season wore on, particularly against left-handed hitters.
The changeup flashes effectiveness as well, especially in its ability to induce softer contact. But again, it lacks the separation needed to be a true out pitch. The knuckle curve, while distinct in movement, profiles more as a contact-management offering than a finisher. Every so often, it would spin up there and get hammered.
The takeaway is not that Montero lacks usable pitches—it’s that none of them individually carry enough weight to prop up a traditional starter profile without pristine execution.
The Second-Half Problem
If there is a clean dividing line in Montero’s season, it comes after the midpoint.
In the second half, his batted-ball profile deteriorated. Hard-hit rate climbed, barrel rate ticked upward, and the margin for error shrank dramatically. His xwOBA rose accordingly, reflecting an increase in quality of contact rather than poor luck alone.
The issue was not walks—his control remained respectable—but rather predictability. Hitters became more comfortable sitting on pitches early in counts, and Montero’s inability to put them away when ahead led to prolonged at-bats and louder contact.
This is where the third-time-through-the-order problem becomes impossible to ignore. Without a true plus pitch, Montero struggles to change the hitter’s eye level or disrupt timing once sequencing is familiar. The data supports what the eye test already suggested: extended starts magnify his weaknesses.
Why the Tigers Are Still Looking For Staters, and Why Montero Still Matters
Detroit’s pursuit of additional pitching depth is rooted in reality. Detroit needs innings. They need stability. They require options that do not rely on perfect execution every night. Montero, at this stage, does not offer that level of certainty.
But that does not mean he lacks value.
In fact, his profile may be better suited for a different usage pattern entirely.
Statcast indicators show that Montero is not getting crushed across the board. His average exit velocity allows him to sit near the league average. His barrel rate, while not elite, is not disastrous. Ground-ball rates remain serviceable. This is not a pitcher being exposed by fundamentally broken stuff.
What he lacks is leverage.
Reframing the 2026 Role
For Montero to be a positive contributor in 2026, the Tigers may need to shift their thinking away from traditional rotation roles and toward flexibility.
A swing-starter or multi-inning relief role could allow his pitch mix to play up. Shorter outings reduce lineup familiarity, allowing the slider and changeup to remain effective weapons rather than survival tools. In two-to-four inning stints, his command profile becomes an asset rather than a liability.
There is also value in depth. Over a full season, innings matter, and Montero has shown he can take the ball without imploding. That alone carries utility for a team navigating injuries, workload management, and prospect development.
There Is Still Something There
The Statcast data does not scream upside, but it does suggest a pitcher who is closer to functional than finished. Montero’s weaknesses are clear—and so are the boundaries of his ceiling. But his strengths, modest as they are, align with roles that modern pitching staffs increasingly rely upon.
Detroit’s continued interest in adding arms is a recognition that they cannot rely on projection alone. But Montero’s presence in the conversation reflects a different truth: development is not always linear, and value does not always come from dominance.
In 2026, Keider Montero may not be a breakout story. However with the right role, the right usage, and the right expectations, he can still be part of the solution, even as the Tigers search for more.
Follow me on "X" @rogcastbaseball