New York Yankees Begin Offseason With Frustrating Move
Nov 16, 2026 12:00 PM

Why exactly did the New York Yankees do this?

The New York Yankees have begun their MLB offseason in frustrating fashion, and it shouldn't come much of a surprise to anyone.

Last winter, the Yankees were largely criticized for "running it back," rolling with essentially the same team from the season prior. They have already shown signs of doing that heading into 2027, as they just signed relief pitcher Tim Hill to a one-year, $2.25 million contract.

Why exactly did New York re-sign Hill?

Yes, I understand he is a lefty who has had plenty of great moments in the Yankees' bullpen. He was terrific after coming over midway through 2024, he was impressive in 2025 and he was solid for the first month this past season ... before he absolutely imploded.

Related stories

Between March and April, Hill logged a 1.42 ERA over 13 appearances. He then posted a 7.45 ERA in May and was horrible the rest of the year, finishing with a 4.60 ERA thanks to surrendering 12 home runs over 58.2 innings of work.

Nine of those homers came from July on, and it made Hill so unreliable that the Yankees left him off their playoff roster entirely.

So why did New York feel the need to retain him?

David Bednar, Paul Blackburn and Ryan Yarbrough are also free agents, so you would think the Yanks would want a significant chunk of money available to either keep them or make external additions. Not that Hill is so expensive, but it's still something, and we know the Yankees are much more financially conscious than they once were.

Hill relies almost exclusively on ground balls to generate outs, and he did induce grounders on 68.8 percent of contact in 2026. The problem is that hitters were squaring up on his pitches far too often.

Is it possible the 36-year-old could rebound from his minus-1.1 WAR campaign? Perhaps, but why even bother testing it? Why not just find a replacement?

The Yankees have gotten far too comfortable with just assuming players will have bounce-back seasons. That's why they keep losing in the playoffs.

New York needs to make some changes, and there are plenty of better relievers than Hill on the market this winter. Re-signing him absolutely wasn't necessary.

It's hard not to be concerned when the first significant move the Yankees made this season was re-upping with a guy who cost them far too much this past year.

Hopefully, it's not the start of a trend.

1
Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy