Yankees' Giancarlo Stanton Decision Forces Obvious Trade
Nov 11, 2026 3:00 PM

The New York Yankees are keeping Giancarlo Stanton, which forces an obvious trade elsewhere.

New York Yankees general manager Brian Cashman has revealed that Giancarlo Stanton will be back with the team next season in spite of speculation that the Yankees could cut ties with him, which does not come as much of a surprise.

We know what Stanton is capable of when he is healthy, and he is also a very well-respected leader in New York's locker room.

But there is also no question that Stanton's return creates a roster glut that must be cleared heading into 2027.

Stanton does not play a position. He is strictly a designated hitter at this point of his career, and you are not going keep a full-time DH on the bench. It would be a waste of a roster spot.

Related stories

But if the Yankees keep their roster as is, that scenario absolutely would occur. Why? Because Ben Rice became the primary designated hitter once New York acquired Luis Garcia Jr. at the MLB trade deadline over the summer.

Garcia became the main first baseman for the Yankees, which forced Rice out of the field and into the DH slot. So if that situation remains intact, Stanton would essentially be a part-time DH off the bench, which doesn't make much sense.

Also, let's remember that Cashman also said the team wants Aaron Judge to DH more in 2027. How will that work with the current setup?

To me, it's a clear indication that Garcia is on the move.

Trading Garcia would allow the Yankees to put Rice back at first base and slide Stanton back into the starting DH role. Judge could then serve as the designated hitter on Stanton's off days, and he typically has a lot of them, even when he is healthy.

I've been saying for quite some time now that Garcia should one hundred percent be a trade candidate this winter, and unless New York wants to move him over to second base (which should not be an option), he should get moved.

Garcia managed a .736 OPS in 43 games with the Yankees in 2026, which is right around his career median of .733. That's decent; not great. And it's important to remember that outside of his first half with the Washington Nationals this past season, where he posted an .873 OPS before getting dealt, he has never been anything more than a pedestrian bat.

The 26-year-old has one year of club control remaining, and it doesn't seem all that likely New York will re-sign him after 2027.

The Yankees might as well trade Garcia now while his value is at its highest rather than wait, convolute the roster and watch as his stock tanks after coming back down to earth next season.

3
Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy