Yankees' Latest Jazz Chisholm Rumor is Beyond Mind-Boggling
Nov 16, 2026 8:42 PM

The New York Yankees' latest Jazz Chisholm rumor is ridiculous.

The New York Yankees have a hole at second base right now with Jazz Chisholm hitting free agency, and the general consensus is that Chisholm is a guaranteed goner.

And why wouldn't he be?

Chisholm was absolutely horrendous this past season, slashing .231/.312/.399 with 19 home runs and 55 RBI over 532 plate appearances. He then batted .182 in the playoffs.

His 2026 campaign was also full of mental mistakes, both in the field and on the basepaths. So there is absolutely no reason to bring him back, right?

Related stories

Well, according to Jim Bowden of The Athletic, the Yankees apparently have not closed the door on a Chisholm reunion, which is enough to make most Yankees fans regurgitate.

Why in the world would New York even consider retaining Chisholm at this point?

The 28-year-old has reportedly received considerable interest around baseball, so he would probably be expensive to re-sign.

Chances are, Chisholm will get a fairly lucrative long-term deal from someone based on how he has performed when he has been at his best, like in 2025 when he smashed 31 homers to go along with an .813 OPS.

But what are the chances of Chisholm actually performing on  a consistent basis?

The seven-year veteran owns a lifetime .245/.315/.444 slash line, which is really only slightly above average. And while he is capable of making some tremendous plays defensively, his glove is questionable depending on what metrics you use ... and how much you've actually watched him.

I get that Brandon Lowe is probably no longer a realistic target for the Yankees given that the Pittsburgh Pirates tendered him a qualifying offer, but why not just pursue Luis Arraez, a three-time batting champion and contact-oriented hitter who would be tremendous at the top of New York's lineup?

It's entirely possible that the Chisholm rumor is just much ado about nothing, because it's hard to imagine the Yankees actually wanting him back. Especially given how much of a headache he gave Aaron Boone throughout significant chunks of 2026.

Plus, Chisholm has a rather checkered injury history, making a multi-year contract that much riskier for the two-time All-Star.

Chisholm definitely had some good moments in the Bronx, and he certainly helped spark the Yanks on their way to a World Series run after coming over midway through 2024.

But his questionable attitude and his lifetime .537 playoff OPS are reasons to say goodbye to him.

1
Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy