Suddenly, in a dog-fight of a first-round series with the Toronto Raptors, the Cleveland Cavaliers continue to let their past playoff struggles define them.
"They're soft."
"They're not mentally tough."
"The lights are too bright."
"Donovan Mitchell can't be a No. 1 option on a championship team."
These are the narratives that seemingly define the Cleveland Cavaliers this time of year. Fair or unfair, they're narratives the franchise just can't seem to shake.
Let's go back to where it all started. Back in 2022-23, the Cavs ended a four-year absence from the postseason by clinching the four seed in the East and drawing the fifth-seeded New York Knicks in the first round.
At the time if was considered a major step for a young core of players that included Donovan Mitchell, Darius Garland, Jarrett Allen and Evan Mobley. Like most young NBA teams, making their first run together in the postseason, they weren't ready for the grind that is the NBA playoffs.
It was Allen who was a little too honest about the experience, dropping the quote that has defined this era of Cavaliers basketball ever since.
"The lights were brighter than expected," he said after being gentleman swept by New York.
And thus, the soft narratives was born.
Cleveland has made the playoffs in each of the three seasons since, each time trying to outrun their reputation. Each year has only produced more moments that make these low hanging fruit talking points bubble back to the surface.
In 2023-24, the Cavs earned the four seed again, but on the last day of the regular season pulled their starters in the second half in order to matchup hunt a first-round series with the Orlando Magic.
The move nearly came back to bite them. Orlando's physical playing style really mucked up the series, going the full-seven games. Naturally, people questioned the team's mettle against more bruising teams.
They advanced, but it wasn't pretty. No one expected them to beat eventual Boston in round two; they didn't, but hey, at least they took the next step by winning a series.
Enter Kenny Atkinson in 2024-25, a move the organization intended to push the team over the top and for most of the regular season, it looked that way. Cleveland jumped out to a torrid 15-0 start to the season. It went on to post the franchise's second-best regular season ever at 64-18 and clinched the number one seed in the conference.
The Cavs' time had finally arrived...or so everyone thought. A buzz saw Indiana Pacers team spoiled that dream, disposing of Cleveland in five games, AGAIN. There was a moment in Game 2 that highlighted how mentally ill-prepared the Cavaliers still were for the postseason.
With 28 seconds left, Max Strus threw the ball away on a sloppy inbound pass that turned into a trip to the line for Pacers star Tyrese Haliburton. He knocked down one-of-two, got his own rebound on the miss and drilled a game-winning three pointer with one second left.
It was as sequence for all intents and purposes ended Cleveland's season. Another second-round exit meant the soft label remained and Donovan Mitchell's legacy remained incomplete, having yet to advance to conference finals in his career.
Now, four games into their 2025-26 playoff run, with new faces like James Harden added to the fold, the conversations are back again. One loss to the Toronto Raptors as their first-round series shifted to their home arena is explainable. It happens. But a second one on Sunday, that saw the Raptors shoot a minuscule 13% from three, but scratch and claw their way to an ugly 93-89 victory was simply inexcusable.
The back-to-back losses pushed Cleveland's road playoff record during this span to 4-10, and only two of the road wins came against teams over 500. Road environments shouldn't be such a daunting thing at this point.
Swapping Garland for Harden at the trade deadline to add a veteran with a wealth of playoff experience was seen as a move to put the team over the top. Meanwhile, all those previous playoff failures should have left enough scars that the Cavs know how to thrive on this stage, not wilt on it.
Instead, history continues to repeat itself, and the same narratives persist, leaving no avenue for anyone outside the organization to defend them anymore.
Only the Cavaliers themselves can change the narratives. That starts Wednesday with Game 5. Mitchell's legacy weighs in the balance. Harden's legacy weighs in the balance. The direction of the franchise weighs in the balance.
Surely they're up for that challenge, right?
Cavaliers Roundtable also offers a fan community and message board. We’d love to have you join us to talk all things Cavaliers. Click the “Join” button at the top of the page to join our community for free.