Nov 21, 2026 9:04 PM

CJ McCollum came off the bench in five straight Kingston Flemings starts. The column argues he should return with more responsibility for Atlanta’s second unit.

The Atlanta Hawks are officially 2-0 without CJ McCollum after beating the Oklahoma City Thunder 117-112 and the Charlotte Hornets 111-97. Is the team better without him?

Some will dismiss this as an overreaction. Fair enough. This is a two-game sample size, and Kingston Flemings missed both games too, so it’s hardly a clean comparison. It is undeniably early to be asking these questions.

Hawks Keep Winning Without McCollum

Dyson Daniels had 10 assists against Charlotte, and Aaron Wiggins scored 19 points in his second straight start. Daniels has already talked about the Hawks pushing the pace with both guards out.

Two wins aren’t extremely significant on their own. Still, even a look at McCollum’s individual stats suggests that there’s some reason for concern.

Related stories

This year, he’s averaging 14.5 points and 3.9 assists per game. Even in his prime, McCollum was a subpar defender. If he’s not providing high-volume, efficient offense, he’s not necessarily helping you win.

Hawks Should Explore Roster Options

The solution could be simple. Keep McCollum and use him as a sixth man.

He already knows the role. McCollum came off the bench in each of the five straight games Flemings started, and he only took back his starting spot in Milwaukee on Nov. 15 because Flemings was out with a lumbar strain. He strained his left calf in that game, and the Hawks will reevaluate him in about four weeks.

It’s a role he’s tailor-made for. McCollum can pilot the offense, doing some scoring and some orchestrating. He can sub in at either guard spot as needed.

That would leave the Hawks with a starting lineup of Flemings, Nickeil Alexander-Walker, Daniels, Jalen Johnson, and Onyeka Okongwu. It’s a strong lineup, full of playmaking and defensive versatility, but it is light on McCollum’s specialty, which is shot creation.

That doesn’t mean it can’t succeed. Alexander-Walker can hit tough shots, and Johnson can create offense with his drive-and-kick game. Still, it does feel like a lineup whose offense could grind to a halt at times.

So, this calls for a twofold solution. The Hawks should bring McCollum off the bench when he returns. If they keep winning, they can run with this group through the trade deadline.

If they don’t, it all circles back to a conversation that’s constantly surrounding the Hawks. They could make a trade. This team has intriguing young players and assets, and a trade is the route if they decide they need a star shot creator to accomplish the season’s goals.

And if they are better without him, that’s nothing to worry about.

1
Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy