May 25, 2026 12:00 PM
As Cleveland teeters on the brink of a postseason sweep, the Cavaliers face a franchise-altering decision: double down on their superstar or trade him for a massive haul.
Donovan Mitchell is one of, if not the best, shooting guards in the NBA, and he has been a catalyst for the Cleveland Cavaliers en route to the Eastern Conference Finals. However, after their historic breakdown in game one against the Knicks at Madison Square Garden, Mitchell and co. have collapsed and are now one game away from being swept.
Mitchell, who is competing in his first ECF, has been with the Cavs since 2022 after a trade with the Utah Jazz that commanded a king's ransom headlined by Lauri Markkanen. Now, the Jazz are set to embark on a new era fueled by the trade return, while Cleveland, who have admittedly improved since Spida’s arrival, has fallen short of their ambitions each season since.
While Mitchell is undoubtedly an x-factor, it’s fair to say that the Cavaliers have hit their ceiling with this current squad. And with Mitchell closing in on a new contract, a decision has to be made. While that decision would be easy for most teams, Cleveland is rumored to potentially have other plans for the former Louisville Cardinal.
So far in the conference finals, Mitchell has averaged 26 points, 3.3 rebounds and 2.7 assists per game while shooting 46.8% from the floor and 32.1% from beyond the arc. Those numbers, while lower than what you’d expect from someone of Spida’s caliber, are still very productive and not conducive to a losing effort in the slightest. Yet, Mitchell may still be on the trading block, especially if his squad fails to win a single game.
Should the Cavs trade him, it’d be hard not to think the Jazz won the trade, especially if they can push for the playoffs next year. Sure, Mitchell would grant Cleveland a franchise-altering haul, but from a strict lens that only focuses on the initial deal, the picks, and Markkanen alone would have provided Utah more long-term value than Spida provided for the Cavs.
An offseason that is already primed to be chaotic may become even more unpredictable if Cleveland reloads. And if Mitchell finds his way back to the Western Conference, Jazz fans would see a lot more of their former Jazzman next season.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableBuilt on infrastructure designed for real-time media. Learn more at RTB.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


