Did the Brooklyn Nets Make the Right Move Leaving New Jersey?
Oct 26, 2026 2:00 PM

Michael Porter Jr.'s comments about opposing fans taking over Barclays Center have reignited an old debate: Did the Nets make the right move from New Jersey to Brooklyn? The financial results speak for themselves, but has the franchise truly benefited?

Michael Porter Jr. recently brought an ongoing debate about the Brooklyn Nets back into the spotlight after describing what it feels like to play at Barclays Center when opposing fans take over the building.

“We just played a preseason game the other night against Philly. You would've thought we were in Philly. We gotta get the Brooklyn Nets fans back in there and actually being louder than the opposing team. When we play Knicks, Celtics, Philly, Lakers, it's mostly their fans. It's crazy.”

His comments raise a question that has followed the franchise since leaving New Jersey in 2012: Did the Nets make the right decision moving to Brooklyn, and has the move lived up to expectations?

From a financial standpoint, it's hard to argue against the decision. But when it comes to winning basketball games and building a passionate fanbase, the results have been much more complicated.

Related stories

When the Nets were still in New Jersey, the franchise wasn't nearly as valuable as it is today. In 2009, the team was valued at approximately $295 million and generated $78.8 million in revenue.

Today, the Nets are worth billions, with recent estimates placing their valuation around $6.5 billion. Annual revenue has also climbed significantly, reaching hundreds of millions of dollars.

The move to Brooklyn certainly wasn't the only reason behind that growth, but it gave the organization opportunities that were much harder to come by in New Jersey. Barclays Center offered a modern arena in a major market, with subway lines and the Long Island Rail Road making it easier for many fans to get to games than it was when the team played in the Meadowlands.

The Nets also gave themselves a fresh identity. The black-and-white color scheme, Brooklyn branding, and connection to the borough helped the franchise stand out. Barclays Center became a destination for concerts and other major events, while the team gained access to a larger market for sponsorships and other business opportunities.

From that perspective, the move accomplished what ownership wanted. The Nets became a much more valuable franchise, and it's difficult to imagine them reaching the same financial heights if they had remained in New Jersey.

The problem is that financial success hasn't translated into an NBA championship.

The Nets have had several opportunities to build a winner in Brooklyn, but they've yet to get over the hump. Early on, the organization traded for Kevin Garnett, Paul Pierce, and Jason Terry, sacrificing valuable draft picks in an attempt to compete immediately. That group didn't deliver the results the franchise expected, and the cost of the deal hurt Brooklyn for years afterward.

Then came the Kevin Durant, Kyrie Irving, and James Harden era. On paper, the trio had the talent to compete for a championship, and for a brief period, the Nets looked like one of the most dangerous teams in the league. Injuries, availability issues, and other problems ultimately prevented them from reaching their potential.

That group eventually fell apart, leaving Brooklyn to start over again.

None of those failures necessarily means the Nets made a mistake by moving. Bad trades, injuries, and unsuccessful roster decisions can happen anywhere. Still, the organization has spent much of its time in Brooklyn trying to find the right formula, and the championship expectations that came with the move have never been fulfilled.

The Knicks' resurgence has made the situation even more interesting. Both teams play in the New York metropolitan area, but the Knicks have a history and following that the Nets haven't been able to match. Even during Brooklyn's most exciting years, the Nets struggled to establish themselves as the city's clear basketball team.

Porter's comments bring another part of that problem into focus. Playing in New York doesn't automatically mean having a building full of home fans.

When the Nets host the Knicks, Celtics, 76ers, or Lakers, plenty of opposing supporters show up. Visiting fans are part of sports, especially in a major market like New York, and a rebuilding team isn't going to attract the same excitement as a contender. Still, hearing a Nets player describe a preseason home game against Philadelphia as feeling like a road game is a reminder that the team has work to do.

Brooklyn has given the franchise a bigger stage, but the Nets still need to turn that opportunity into a stronger connection with their own fans. Winning would help, and so would giving supporters a team they can believe in for more than a season or two.

There's also a part of this debate that shouldn't be overlooked: New Jersey.

The Nets spent 35 seasons in the Garden State, including their memorable runs to the NBA Finals in 2002 and 2003. Those teams, led by Jason Kidd and later featuring players such as Vince Carter, gave New Jersey fans plenty of memories. For supporters who followed the franchise before 2012, that history still matters.

The organization has made some efforts to embrace that past through throwback uniforms and tributes to its New Jersey years. It should continue doing so. Moving to Brooklyn didn't erase the team's history, and there's no reason to act as if the franchise only became relevant when it arrived at Barclays Center.

New Jersey Governor Mikie Sherrill has also expressed interest in bringing the Nets back to the state. While that idea might appeal to longtime fans, there is currently no indication that the franchise is preparing to leave Brooklyn.

From a business perspective, a return to New Jersey would be difficult to justify. The Nets have a modern arena, a valuable brand, and access to one of the country's biggest markets. Moving again wouldn't automatically fix the team's basketball problems or guarantee a more loyal fanbase.

The better approach would be to keep building in Brooklyn while doing a better job of recognizing the people and history that helped make the franchise what it is today.

Ultimately, I think the Nets made the right decision leaving New Jersey. The financial growth alone makes that argument difficult to dismiss, and Barclays Center offers advantages the organization didn't have in the Meadowlands. The move gave the franchise a stronger foundation, even if the results on the court haven't always matched the investment.

That doesn't mean everything has worked out as planned. The Nets still haven't won a championship in Brooklyn, and Porter has made it clear that getting more home fans behind the team remains a concern.

The move itself isn't the problem. What the Nets do with the opportunities Brooklyn provides is what matters now. If they can develop their young players, build a competitive roster, and give fans a reason to show up beyond the visiting team's star power, the atmosphere at Barclays Center can change.

For now, the Nets have a franchise worth billions but are still searching for the kind of sustained success that turns casual supporters into lifelong fans. Brooklyn was the right move for the business. The next challenge is making it feel just as right for the people in the stands.

1
Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy