Why AJ Dybantsa Should Be Washington Wizards' Top Overall Pick

The Washington Wizards are still searching for the player who can ultimately become the face of their rebuild and franchise. While there are multiple supremely worthy candidates to be taken number 1 overall, including Cam Boozer and Darryn Peterson, AJ Dybantsa still sticks out as the obvious fit for the front office.

Dybantsa offers the combination of elite production, NBA-ready physical tools, rim pressure, and superstar wing upside that every front office covets. More importantly, he directly addresses one of the Wizards' biggest weaknesses.

Washington desperately needs a player who can collapse defenses and apply rim pressure at will.

Last season, the Wizards ranked 26th in the NBA in free throws made per game (16.2) and 26th in free-throw attempts per game (21.2). Those numbers reveal a team that struggled to consistently pressure the rim and force defenses into rotation. The reason Dybantsa is so appealing is because Washington currently lacks a true offensive engine capable of consistently getting downhill and breaking down opposing defenses.

Bub Carrington has shown encouraging signs as a shooter, but he is not a player who consistently generates paint touches against NBA defenders. Tre Johnson projects as a possible three level scorer, but he doesn’t necessarily project to be an impact downhill threat as his game is more perimeter based. Kyshawn George possesses intriguing creation skills, while Will Riley may ultimately become Washington's best defense-collapsing prospect currently on the roster.

But Dybantsa is different.

He projects as a player who can pressure defenses from day one.

His combination of size, explosiveness, body control, and handle allows him to consistently get two feet in the paint and force help defenders to react. Once defenses collapse, everything else opens up. Shooters like Bub, Kyshawn, and Tre will get cleaner looks. Bigs receive easier opportunities around the rim. The offense becomes more efficient because defenders are constantly scrambling.

Among elite wing prospects, Dybantsa's free-throw production is extraordinary:

Dybantsa's foul-drawing profile is arguably most comparable to Kevin Durant among elite wing prospects. Even more impressive, he recorded 229 made free throws during his freshman season, an elite mark that highlights both his aggressiveness and ability to finish through contact.

But the case for Dybantsa extends beyond his ability to get to the line.

His freshman season at BYU was one of the most productive campaigns we've seen from a future NBA prospect in recent years.

The numbers are difficult to ignore:

Dybantsa isn't simply a high-volume scorer. He impacts every aspect of the game.

His 25.5 points per game led all of Division I basketball, making him the nation's leading scorer as a freshman. That's an accomplishment very few future NBA stars can claim.

His 894 total points led the nation, while his 51 percent field-goal percentage demonstrates remarkable efficiency for a player carrying such a large offensive burden as he had a 33.5% usage rate which ranked him in the 99th percentile. His 6.8 rebounds and 3.7 assists also showcase a well-rounded game that extends beyond scoring.

Peterson is an outstanding prospect and could absolutely develop into an NBA superstar. His shot creation, scoring instincts, and offensive polish are undeniable.

However, the combination of production, size, and archetype, in my opinion, favors Dybantsa over Peterson.

Put the stats and archetype’s aside, because you put an asterisk on all of Darryn Peterson’s stats due to his injuries and being used differently at Kansas. My main argument for Dybantsa over Peterson is that there are still questions regarding Peterson’s ability to withstand a grueling 82 game season schedule. Betting on Peterson regaining his high school level of burst and athleticism is a risk that I may not be willing to take when you have standout prospects like Dybantsa and Boozer on the board. There is certainly a scenario where Peterson becomes the best player from this draft class, and while I do believe Peterson has all the makings of a franchise player, there still is a bit of risk attached to Peterson that he will unfortunately never shake off until he reaches the NBA. There are zero questions regarding Peterson’s talent, and anyone that drafts him over outstanding prospects like Dybantsa and Boozer should be 100% confident in his medicals and ability to play at least 70 games each season. 

The Wizards need more than another talented prospect.

They need a player capable of transforming and representing their franchise.

AJ Dybantsa's production suggests he can do it. His physical tools suggest he can do it. His elite rim pressure addresses one of Washington's most glaring weaknesses, and his ability to collapse defenses would immediately elevate the entire roster around him.

With all of this rambling in mind, in my humble opinion, draft AJ Dybantsa and make him the centerpiece of the rebuild.

Wizards Roundtable also offers a fan community. We’d love to have you join us to talk all things Wizards. Create an account, click the “Join” button at the top of the page to join our free community and follow for all of our coverage, analysis and more!