Nov 16, 2026 4:19 PM

Alabama Crimson Tide coach Kalen DeBoer needs to straighten things out.

The Alabama Crimson Tide once dominated the recruiting circuit like no other, but the program has taken a massive hit over the last couple of years.

That latest example came in the form of four-star running back Nigel Newkirk, who decided to flip his 2027 commitment from Alabama to Ohio State over the weekend.

Alabama's 2027 recruiting class ranks 35th in the country and now features just one running back: three-star prospect Tai Phillips.

Newkirk had been committed to the Crimson Tide since last May, but he decided to make a nine-hour drive to Columbus to watch the Buckeyes beat Northwestern on Saturday.

Related stories

That was a bad sign for Alabama, and it didn't take long afterward for Newkirk to commit his talents to Ohio State.

And Crimson Tide head coach Kalen DeBoer has himself to blame.

Newkirk made it abundantly clear before flipping his commitment that he would like to see 'Bama run the football more. And what happened on Saturday? Alabama finished with under 100 rushing yards in its fourth straight game during a win over Vanderbilt.

That essentially sealed the deal for Newkirk, who had clearly seen enough.

Alabama offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb has absorbed plenty of criticism for his play calling throughout the season, and rightfully so. It has been questionable, at best.

But let's be honest: this starts up top.

DeBoer is the head coach. Grubb was his offensive coordinator at Washington. He then brought him aboard in Tuscaloosa. Ultimately, he is responsible, and it just cost him a pivotal recruit in a class in which Alabama was already struggling mightily.

We can blame Grubb as much as we want, but DeBoer is the man in charge. It's his responsibility to ensure his coordinators are making the right decisions, and he obviously knew that Newkirk's commitment was on the line over the weekend.

To be quite frank, Newkirk had probably already had his mind made up when he made the trip to Columbus. But Alabama had plenty of time before then to assuage his doubts.

The Crimson Tide didn't do that, and now, their lack of a consistent rushing attack might alienate other top running back prospects, as well.

Alabama has bagged five commitments for the class of 2028. No halfbacks yet, though, and that could end up being a significant problem.

And for as much as 'Bama fans want to point the finger at Grubb, DeBoer is to blame.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy