Alabama Holds No. 3 CFP Ranking, but the Tide Still Has Something to Prove
Nov 18, 2026 5:45 AM

Despite a lofty top-four placement, Kalen DeBoer’s squad must overcome offensive inconsistencies and a two-loss resume to prove they truly belong among the national championship elite.

Two losses.

A season filled with ups and downs.

And somehow, Alabama finds itself sitting at No. 3 in the College Football Playoff rankings.

Folks, if you had told me a few weeks ago that Alabama would be sitting in this position heading into the final stretch of the regular season, I'm not sure I would have believed you.

Related stories

But here we are.

The College Football Playoff selection committee released its latest rankings Tuesday night, and Kalen DeBoer's Crimson Tide remained at No. 3 following Saturday's 21-6 road victory over Vanderbilt.

Alabama, now 8-2, sits behind No. 1 Georgia and No. 2 Utah, with undefeated UCLA rounding out the top four. And while some fans around the country are questioning how a two-loss Alabama team deserves to be ranked ahead of several programs with better records, I think there's a bigger conversation worth having.

Alabama has put itself in position to compete for a national championship. But has this team played consistently enough to look like a national championship contender?

That's the question.

And if we're being fair, the answer isn't quite as simple as looking at the rankings.

Let's give Alabama credit where it's due.

The Crimson Tide has faced a challenging schedule, battled through adversity and found ways to win games that could have easily gone in the opposite direction. Alabama's 31-13 victory over LSU in Baton Rouge was a statement win. It showed what this team is capable of when its offense, defense and coaching staff are all working together.

But then came Vanderbilt.

Yes, Alabama won. Yes, the defense held the Commodores to six points. And yes, winning on the road in the SEC is never something to take for granted.

But offensively? Goodness gracious, there were some frustrating moments. We've seen it throughout the season. Alabama struggles to establish an offensive rhythm early, puts itself in difficult situations and then depends on second-half adjustments or individual performances to get things moving.

And while I'm thankful this team continues finding ways to win, I don't believe Alabama can afford those inconsistencies against the nation's best teams.

Not in December. And certainly not in the College Football Playoff.

The Tide's two losses came against Georgia and Tennessee, and both games exposed areas that Alabama must continue addressing. That doesn't mean Alabama isn't deserving of its ranking. The selection committee clearly values the Tide's strength of schedule and quality victories.

But being ranked No. 3 and playing like the third-best team in the country every Saturday are two different things. I've said it before, and I'll say it again: Alabama doesn't have a talent problem.

This roster has the athletes, depth and potential to compete with anybody in college football.

What Alabama needs is consistency.

Offensively, that starts with establishing a running game, protecting the quarterback and finding ways to sustain drives without relying on explosive plays to bail the team out. Quarterback Keelon Russell has shown tremendous potential, and I believe he continues growing into the leadership role this program needs. But Alabama cannot expect its quarterback to overcome every offensive breakdown.

The offensive line has to do its part. The running game has to become more reliable. And offensive coordinator Ryan Grubb has to find ways to get this offense moving before Alabama finds itself playing from behind.

Defensively, I've been encouraged by the energy and physicality Kane Wommack's unit has demonstrated. Holding Vanderbilt to six points was impressive, especially considering the offensive struggles Alabama experienced throughout the game. That defense has the potential to be the difference-maker in close postseason matchups. But the entire team has to work together.

Championship football requires complementary football.

A great defensive performance means even more when the offense can control possession, establish momentum and capitalize on opportunities. And that's what I want to see from Alabama moving forward.

Now, here's something else worth remembering.

The College Football Playoff rankings aren't the final destination. They're simply a reflection of where teams stand right now.

Alabama still has Chattanooga on November 21 before welcoming Auburn to Bryant-Denny Stadium for the Iron Bowl on November 28. And anybody who knows anything about Alabama football knows you never overlook Auburn.

Records don't matter in that rivalry. Rankings don't matter. And playoff expectations certainly don't guarantee anything. Alabama has to finish the regular season strong and continue proving that it belongs among the nation's elite.

Personally, I think this team has the potential to make a serious postseason run. But potential only gets you so far. At some point, Alabama has to put together four complete quarters of football against quality competition.

No unnecessary mistakes. No disappearing offense. No waiting until halftime to make adjustments.

Just Alabama football.

Physical.

Disciplined.

Relentless.

The kind of football that built this program into a national powerhouse. And before anybody misunderstands me, I'm not suggesting DeBoer has to be Nick Saban. He's his own coach, building his own program. But the standard at Alabama didn't leave when Saban retired.

That standard is about competing for championships, developing players and expecting excellence every single Saturday. And right now, Alabama has an opportunity to do exactly that.

My biggest takeaway from Tuesday night's rankings? Alabama has earned a seat at the table. Now it's time to prove the Crimson Tide belongs there.

Being No. 3 in November is exciting. But nobody hangs banners for November rankings. They hang banners for championships.

And if Alabama wants another one, the Crimson Tide has to continue improving, eliminate the inconsistencies and play its best football when it matters most.

The opportunity is right in front of them.

Now let's see what they do with it.

Roll Tide.

Comments
anonymous profile image
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy