Nov 6, 2026 4:05 AM
Updated Nov 7, 2026 6:24 PM
From Ty Detmer’s Heisman-caliber dominance to Austin Collie’s fourth-down magic, revisit the legendary icons who defined BYU’s dominance and heartbreak throughout the most intense rivalry in college football.
Every year college football debates the best rivalries. In 2026, there is no debate. No other rivalry in the sport will mean as much this year as the Holy War. There are always bragging rights at stake. This year there is much more than that for the BYU Cougars.
BYU’s best Holy War players by decade
1990s – QB Ty Detmer
Ty Detmer had a truly impressive career at BYU. He finished his career with over 15,000 yards, 121 touchdowns and led the WAC in passing for three of his four years. Detmer’s performance in the 1990s led many at that time to believe BYU was on its way to becoming quarterback U.
In the 1990 Holy War game, Detmer did not disappoint. He passed for 451 yards and five touchdowns en route to a 45-22 BYU victory. Detmer threw four first half touchdowns, three in the second quarter alone. Detmer went on to win the Heisman Trophy that season. Additional Detmer note, the year before, in 1989, he led BYU to their most points scored in the rivalry’s history, winning 70-31.
2000s – RB Luke Staley, WR Austin Collie
Luke Staley had a solid career with BYU, but one season towered above the rest. He finished with 2,507 rushing yards. 1,596 of that came in 2001. His yards, touchdowns and unbelievable 8.1 yards per carry led the Mountain West Conference. His 2001 Holy War performance will not soon be forgotten.
Related stories
In 2001, Staley rushed for 169 yards and two touchdowns. Like his season stats, his yards per carry average in that game was unheard of at almost 10 yards per carry (9.9). That was almost a first down every time he touched the ball. With a little over two minutes remaining in the game, Staley took a Brandon Doman pitch 30 yards to seal the BYU win after trailing 21-10 in the fourth quarter.
Before Austin Collie became a go-to option for Peyton Manning and the Indianapolis Colts, there was Collie coming in the clutch for the Cougars in 2007. Collie’s 2008 season would be his best season, but in 2007, throwing to Collie created unexpected magic.
Trailing late in the fourth quarter, the Cougars were faced with an impossible 4th and 18. Facing pressure, quarterback Max Hall heaved a deep pass down the sideline. Collie beat his defender and made a mid-route adjustment, hauling in the 49-yard pass and converting the much-needed first down. BYU would eventually win that game 17-10.
2010s – QB Taysom Hill
Taysom Hill might have been a dual-threat surprise to many NFL fans, but his 2013 season was when BYU fans knew. Hill’s passing numbers alone don’t register among BYU’s greatest passers. However, his dual-threat ability created real problems for opponents. In 2013, Hill ran the ball for an astounding 259 yards vs Texas. His 2013 Holy War game did not see rushing totals that high, but the dual-threat aspect was something Utah could not contain.
The Holy War game was not his most efficient passing day at 37%. His 260 passing yards and 99 rushing yards proved challenging for Utah, but the Utes would eventually win late 20-13. The weather conditions created a tough defensive matchup. Though Utah struggled to contain Hill, they would eventually win a close and gritty game 20-13.
BYU and Utah have only played three times in the last six years, making the 2020s incomplete. The anticipation of this year’s battle and the raised stakes of two top ten teams, could provide BYU with their 2020s best performance in the Holy War.
On Saturday, November 7, BYU will travel to Salt Lake City for the 104th meeting between these two programs.
Comments
Powered by RoundtableAn AI/DeFi-powered Enterprise Media Operating System. Learn more at Roundtable.io.© Roundtable 2026. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy


