Once a powerhouse in college football, Florida State is now fighting a different battle—one not defined by tradition, but by money. In the NIL era, recruiting success is no longer about prestige alone, and the Seminoles are feeling the gap more than ever.
Once the standard in college football, Florida State Seminoles no longer dominate the way it once did.
Part One of this four-part series focused on how Florida State got to the point of being considered irrelevant. Part Two shifts to recruiting, and whether Florida State can compete with other programs in attracting top talent in this new landscape.
Pete Nakos on Wake Up Warchant called Florida State “middle of the pack” when it comes to spending.
The problem is that we live in a world where spending plays a major role in success in modern college football and in how teams are built. The days when a program’s prestige played a massive role in recruiting are over.
Traditional blue blood programs are increasingly being overtaken by programs with greater financial backing green bloods. Programs with the resources to spend at a high level on acquiring talent.
Kirby Smart simply stated, “A lot of these kids want a check.”
It appears Florida State is not spending what it takes to compete with the top programs in the country.
The Nakos’ comments about Florida State being middle-of-the-road, means their simply not playing the same game as the other top programs. When the elite teams are in the $30–$50 million range and you are spending around $20 million, the talent gap becomes too large for almost any coach to overcome.
CollegeFrontOffice.com uses a model to estimate how NIL resources are used to construct a roster. While they do say no model is perfect, they state on their site, “Our current model produces valuations within 20% of market consensus for most starters, and our high school recruit valuations track independent estimates at a median ratio of 1.0×.”
According to their model, the top 17 teams in the country spent roughly $47.9 million to $32.1 million, while Florida State sits at the $27.6 million mark. With such a significant gap in funding, is it fair to hold Mike Norvell to the same expectations as those higher-funded programs?
Even within their own conference, the Seminoles rank only third behind the Miami Hurricanes at $45.4 million and the Clemson Tigers at $28.4 million. And those numbers will only continue to rise if enforceable rules with real consequences are not put in place to control them.
On3 JD Pickell on his show relayed the following from Athlon: “This ACC assistant via Athlon had this to say about Florida State, quote, they don’t have the booster support that people might think that they do.” The quote came from an anonymous assistant coach in the same conference as the program being discussed.
On the other hand another reason money may have started to dry up is the number of major capital projects the university has taken on over the last five years. Florida State University has renovated its football stadium, built a standalone football facility, expanded campus housing and dining, and added Legacy Hall.
At some point, you have to ask: how many times can you continue going back to the same pockets for more money before the answer starts to be no?
But regardless of the reason, if Mike Norvell or whoever is in charge, the reality is that winning in today’s college football landscape requires money. Regardless of who the coach is, if the school can’t give him the resources to compete, you’re not going to compete at the highest level.
As Hall of Fame coach and now Michigan Wolverines head coach Kyle Whittingham explained, “what it takes to win in college football in this day and age, in this order: great resources in the NIL area and space, outstanding players which ties right into how much NIL you have and then, a coaching staff that’s competent.”
It’s the lack of resources that may explain why Florida State only has seven commitments at this point. It also helps explain why landing the nation’s No. 726 overall prospect and the No. 40 quarterback in the class feels like a major recruiting win in Tallahassee.
Norvell’s future has become a major topic surrounding the program, with reports indicating that Florida State leadership strongly considered making a coaching change after last season. That uncertainty only makes recruiting more difficult, as elite high school prospects and transfer portal players typically want stability before committing to a program.
In today’s college football landscape, programs with the strongest NIL resources and financial backing hold the advantage, and right now Florida State is operating against schools in a completely different spending tier.
Until the Seminoles close that financial gap and create greater stability in recruiting, their ability to win consistently on the field will remain limited.
Join our ROUNDTABLE community! It's free to join. Share your thoughts, engage with our Roundtable writers, and chat with fellow members.
Download the free Roundtable APP, and stay even more connected!
